That’s weird, I didn’t think Redshirts was really that funny. Honestly, I though it was pretty bleak, although in the final third or so I thought it was really excellent.
I definitely thought it was going to be funny, but instead of "ha ha, we're all going to die!" it was "oh god, we're all going to die!". Still, by the time I got to the final bit (if you've read it, you know the part I'm talking about), I thought it was really excellent.