I like Alexander quite a bit, except for his tendency to intellectual cultishness. The 4-volume set he recently came out with (after 30 years) has a lot of good stuff in it, but it's marred by gobs of insufferable nonsense about being the greatest this-or-that of the last 1600 years. Like most gurus, the man doesn't need an entourage of epigones. What he needs is an editor.
Edit: there's another thing that bugs me about Alexander (though I really am a fan). It's that the photos of his actual buildings I've seen don't seem to live up to the genius of the things he says about how to make buildings. That incongruity gives me pause. Of course, one wouldn't expect him to make grand or immodest buildings in any way (that would be even more incongruous). Perhaps one has to experience them in person.
I'm not an architect either.
It may be that he's a brilliant/inspiring communicator and a competent practitioner. Others like this (to my mind) are Douglas R Hofstadner and David Flanagan. We need inspiring writers; it's a good thing.
http://www.katarxis3.com/Gallery/community/community.htm
http://www.patternlanguage.com/pbrochure/purplebrochurehead....
Ha, this is my first time to the Pattern Language website... It's clear that while Alexander may understand patterns in architecture, he has very little understanding of patterns in web design.