I don't see why this is a good feature for the user. I just want to play it.
That said, there has been consistent feedback that people want to play old puzzles, myself included. At least for me, the replay value is actually pretty solid after a few days' opportunity of forgetting the solution. So the next big feature I'm working on is the puzzle archive. Stay tuned!
I suspect this combo of a new daily puzzle and the complete archive will be the winning implementation over time.