Yes/no/whatever. Someone else would've created something similar eventually. Same with the Oppenheimer and the atomic bomb.
Yes/no/whatever. Someone else would've created something similar eventually. Same with the Oppenheimer and the atomic bomb.
If you invent low-height bridges to keep black people out of select neighborhoods (because they tend to take the bus, and busses can't cross the bridge / tunnel), would you just be "someone else would have created something similar eventually??".
As an engineer, you are responsible for your inventions. That's always been true. Ideally, you create things for people who are trustworthy.
If you don't care about ethics, then don't be surprised if those ethics come to bite you in the ass later. Is it "just a low height bridge", or is it a "racist bridge"? As an engineer, its your job to make the thing (or decide to not make the thing).
Disagree. Feel free to design whatever you want. The person actually building and putting it to use would be the one at fault.
Yes. And if you design a racist bridge designed to keep black people out of a neighborhood, you're either helping racists, or are racist yourself.
Feel free to be whatever you want, but accept that if you make racist decisions it makes you a racist.
Now replace "racism" with whatever other adjective is out there (face-tracking software, guns, etc. etc.) and its really the same thing. We engineers must ethically agree with the things we make, and their expected use. Its one thing if maybe our boss uses the device in a way we didn't expect. But on the other hand, Oppenheimer knew damn well what he was making.
The people we support and work for are ethically and morally tied to us engineers. They can only do the things they want with our support. And we are tied with them, since their use of our inventions is actually quite predictable in most situations.
And furthermore, even nuclear bombs had a plausible ethical use (end the war sooner).
If Facebook is 100% evil, then it behooves the workers to work for a less evil company, at a minimum. Of course, Facebook itself isn't 100% evil so things break down in your example.
If you're a React.js developer and you're worried about internet privacy, intrusive ad-tech being used to track people (etc. etc.), then maybe... just maybe... you should find something else to work on in a company that matches your ethics better.
Some things have no real ethical use.
At least in some cases inventors are unethical to invent some things.
Or working on better ads for scammers.
Or trying to invent legal loophole to enable something evil.
Could they have been used in another manner? Yes. But we all know what the intent was, and any engineer who worked on that project knew damn well what was going on.
[ I am an Engineer.
In my profession I take deep pride. To it I owe solemn obligations.
As an engineer, I, (full name), pledge to practice Integrity and Fair Dealing, Tolerance, and Respect, and to uphold devotion to the standards and dignity of my profession, conscious always that my skill carries with it the obligation to serve humanity by making best use of the Earth's precious wealth.
As an engineer, I shall participate in none but honest enterprises. When needed, my skill and knowledge shall be given without reservation for the public good.
In the performance of duty, and in fidelity to my profession, I shall give the utmost.]Ideas require free flow of ideas, concepts, experiments. If the bridge happens to be "racist" (what a dumb example) then so what. Let the person you pitch it to (if you get that far) point it out and go from there. If it passes initial examination and goes as far as to actually getting built, I'm way past washing my hands off any guilt.
Edit: And your example is equally weird. Who in their right mind would ever design a bridge that was 0.001% safe? There are a ton of people up the chain who make way dumber (and "RACIST") decisions if they go ahead and build the contraption.
(less if they were forced/unaware or there are somehow other mitigating reasons)
The same goes for other designer of things that could be clearly put into primarily or only bad use.
If you agree with the above statement, then the basic rationalization of "I didn't directly do it, therefore I am innocent" holds. But if you disagree with the above statement, you acknowledge that simply not being the person who "pulls the trigger" does not absolve you of doing the work leading up to it.
Or put another way: "All it takes for evil to triumph is for good men to design their death camps."
To a point. Intention and context matter more. If you build low-height bridges because at the time it was the economical thing to do, and perhaps not even considering bus sizes, then you are not responsible. This happens ALL THE TIME in software.
When I talk about "racist bridges", I'm talking about the well known case of Robert Moses. Most people who have studied the ethics of engineering should be familiar with him.
It is pretty widely accepted that he did this to keep "certain people" away from the public beaches.
[1] 'racism' is not the same as racism [2]
[2] https://www.britannica.com/topic/racism
[3] https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20...
It appears to share its pedigree with a number of German firearms from the WW2 era, the designers of which just so happened to "immigrate" to the Soviet Union in 1945.
The Soviets wouldn't have found it very palatable to field a weapon designed by Germans, and the story of a common soldier designing one of the great battle rifles of the 20th Century and being elevated to a Hero of the Soviet Union as a result is great propaganda.
I'm not asserting that the man had nothing to do with it, don't get me wrong. It's just very obviously not the work of one individual's mind, and given the context of the era we should probably take a critical view of the official story.
Unlike AK which is exceedingly simple.
I think only thing is the inspiration for class of weapon which time had clearly come. Something beyond sub-machine gun. With decent single shot accuracy.
Getting older sucks sometimes, but it beats the alternative!
You can see a comparison done by a popular AK builder/engineer here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4l33puWET0
I don't think this reasoning works. A few years ago I turned down a job at an MLM after digging through their mandated public filings and determining that almost everyone who worked with them ended up underwater. More recently I turned down a very well paying job in a financial investment company after reflecting on the fact that they didn't produce anything, or provide any services and instead took a (lower paying) job writing software for hospitals/medical clinics. They basically existed to leach of the market.
My point is that I think if you build something knowing full well how it will be used, you carry a certain amount of responsibility when it is indeed used that way. You don't get to absolve yourself of responsibility because someone else is doing the has their hand on the trigger/button. You wired that trigger/button knowing what it was for.
"Someone else would do it anyway" could be used to justify anything. To go full Goodwin it could be used to justify "just following orders" under the Nazis. After all someone else would've done it anyway.
You're welcome.