One of my hobbies is rescuing these devices from E-Waste, so I'm acutely aware of them. The huge difference is that these devices are usually pretty out-of-date.
Sure, that first generation iPad that went into an otterbox on day one is just fine, mechanically. But can a normal person use it to do much of anything useful? The youtube app doesn't work. Safari won't load any webpages. The app store loads, but most apps (even compatible ones!) won't install.
Not even just things being "too slow", they can't speak modern protocols.
Printers haven't changed that much. When's the last time there was a change to PostScript that made old printers not just obsolete, but unusable?
These printers are designed to fail.
There's enough E-Waste being generated without these sorts of anti-user moves.
Those old devices you're talking about were thrown out because they are old. Not because they were designed to fail. I pull PowerBooks from this era out of the trash literally every week. They're basically useless to anyone but collectors. They still work! But they're not very useful for modern tasks, for most people. Sure, giganerds like me can get use out of them. But good luck finding software to run on them...
The waste pad on every professional grade inkjet printer I've ever seen is a snap-fit part that costs under $25.
But no, defend this practice of throwing away a printer because a sponge is saturated.
In this case, the printers are literally designed to fail. Once you get to an arbitrary number of uses, you can no longer use them, independently of the device state.
Canon TS302 Wireless Inkjet Printer https://a.co/d/3SjlJbB (not Epson, but cheap inkjet; there were a handful of Epsons under $100).
I solved this problem for our house in the sensible way: with a color HP3600N laser and a B&W multi-function HP (I think a 252), but there’s clearly a cost to make a part user-serviceable that doesn’t strictly have to be and if you’re trying to sell a printer in the $50-90 range, $5 of parts matters.
The outrage is that Epson printers (might?) have a secret page counter and the printers kill themselves after a certain number of pages whether or not the ink pads still work. Even if the user replaces the ink pads, the printer will still refuse to work because the counter is used up.
This sort of behavior is unethical, user hostile, and should be criminal.
Yes it is, and yes it should be. But even if it isn't criminal, it is just begging for a class-action lawsuit.
But all of this is very specific and complex so there isn’t enough demand for laws to mandate such things.
I think the problem is with the fact that this is just not disclosed properly, before a purchase decision is made, as it's not apparent that such a expiry mechanism can exist!
But it definitely wouldn't harm them, so even if the expected benefit is small it's still net positive. Whether it is worth their time to evaluate the market should be the customer's decision to make.