Not even trying to delay ship or get future rework scheduled, just having it documented is too much. Out of sight out of mind.
Not even trying to delay ship or get future rework scheduled, just having it documented is too much. Out of sight out of mind.
If you roll your own thing, even if it's objectively better, you're painting a target on your back. Now when your new thing fails it's your fault.
There's also something to be said for how modern financial capitalism has squeezed redundancy out of everything. Supply chains are just-in-time, businesses rely on a million vendors for everything, if a single link in the chain fails it usually has a huge blast radius because of broad consolidation in these upstream suppliers. Basically there are a lot of small businesses that depend on like 5 large companies (think Sysco, telecoms, etc) and if those large companies fail every small company fails in the same way, so there's no incentive to derisk (because your competitors will all also be failing in the same way).
Once the initial investment in creating a stock of those items is done, there's only a minimal storage cost. For things like chips for cars, that storage cost is probably measured in double-digit dollars a year to create billions of dollars worth of vehicles.
Is investing in a business to smooth over supply chain problems really so taboo to a modern businessman?
If by "modern financial capitalism" you mean "customers who prefer cheaper to superior quality of product and/or service", then I agree with you.
We can't buy what doesn't exist after all.
You and your competition produce two equivalent products. They sell theirs for $100: do you feel confident in pricing yours at $110 and base your commercial copy on "We rely on a more robust logistic chain in case of a world-wide catastrophe"?
And it is an investment, not an ongoing significant cost. Once you have a local surplus established, you can simply buy what you use going forward - the same as any other JIT manufacturing process - with a minimal ongoing cost for storage space.
As such, a businessman who wishes to invest in the in the longevity of the business over maximizing this year's profits would be happy to sacrifice some profit for the ability to remain solvent in the next supply chain breakdown.
Because there will be another one.
Hence the automotive/chips and other recent shortages...
I see people recognizing reality - JIT is efficient but fragile in the face of disruption.
Seems to me the sensible thing to do would be to recognize that for what it is and try to strike the right balance in an uncertain world. Even if your concerns are strictly commercial, a couple points margin in good times is unlikely to balance a year of massively screwed up supply chains.
Chips do not fall into this category.
Because it wasn't in the company I work for, and it wasn't at many of our suppliers, and it looks like similar things happened most everywhere else.
We've made a number of changes, both to how and where we source things, to how much of what we keep in stock, and changed processes to re-evaluate suppliers and overall state-of-the-market more frequently.
I know some of our vendors have as well, both because in some cases we asked them to, and also just from talking to them.
If your firm has achieved planning perfection, congrats. I mean that sincerely. But I don't think a lot of other places have.
The irony runs deep with that tidbit.
Not every single supply chain in a nation!
From the parent:
> because it was a component whose manufacturing flexability is pretty minimal
in de 90's i had a business fail because the phone company never connected my land line (and kept lying about it) it would have failed a lot faster if there wasn't a pay phone in front of the building.
Shops could still fail back on cash a few years ago but now many have a card or a phone to pay and nothing else.
3-4 decades ago regular customers often got credit at their local store, bar or lunchroom.
We seem to increasingly do stuff without a plan B
Car manufacturers have the nasty habit of keeping no stock —at all— even of inexpensive stuff like microchips, smd components, nuts, bolts... and ordering everything "just in time", while at the same time maintaining a steel-fisted strangle-hold on suppliers which are obliged to provide them what's needed when, or die.
For those components that are used by multiple different automakers (and others) wouldn't it make more sense for the component manufacturers to be the ones stocking?
This MCH speaker suggests 3 micro-controllers is all it takes to build a fully functional and road-safe electric car, and explains the current situation about auto manufacturing:
https://media.ccc.de/v/mch2022-77-electric-vehicles-are-goin...
No, it's also so they can do really important stuff like remotely disabling your heated seats.
Being an "asshole" isn't always a bad thing, assuming you mean "frowned upon for providing dissent along lines of unhappy, but factual, technical realities which are applicable in the current context".
If this is the new definition of asshole, then I am the king of assholes.
Being able to sell a "no" is much more important than being able to sell someone on a shiny piece of bullshit.
It's that there's an economic incentive to not care. So they don't.
Build quality, keep redundancy, and in the next pandemic your business will flourish... unless you'll have had to close it before 'cause of people buying cheap and not good!
On the business side, Toyota - the progenator of JIT manufacturing who still warehoused chips to deal with a shortage exactly like what happened - flourished at a time where others floundered. As an added bonus, they were still able to remain profitable prior to the shortage, despite having warehoused chips.
I think the "buy cheap not good" is more of a proactive excuse from companies who want to sell cheap goods to maximize their profit. Kind of an extension of the "never ask customers what they want, they'd just want better horses" or "they can have it in any color so long as it's black" tropes.
This is not what I meant. Customers did not care, before the pandemic.
It's Risk. Humans are typically insanely bad at understanding risk, how to assess it, and how to mitigate it.
For most, if something is risky, it's just a black box, perhaps with some odds, and it's either feared or ignored (or both).
Few understand the critical difference between using knowledge, skill, technology, and planning to manage and mitigate risk, vs rolling the dice and getting away with it for a long time.
Using knowledge, skill, technology, and planning to manage and mitigate risk has gotten humans to great heights - we can make entire careers living in environments in which random behaviors will kill us in seconds (e.g., aerospace, underwater, large construction, metals refining, etc.).
But most people think much more naively, and even do so in professional environments unless required otherwise (and even sometimes where they are). So, they just think that if something isn't obviously a risk, or only happens occasionally, ignore it.
This is just rolling the dice. Even if you get away with it for a long time, that only makes you more falsely confident and therefore more vulnerable. From the last mild pandemic, there are over a million dead and close to half million suffering long disease from this attitude.
And you see it in your work - you simply point out an obvious very damaging failure mode, even just to document it, and you get a hostile reaction.
I'm not sure what to do about it. Perhaps rock climbing should be a required activity in school, learning to viscerally manage risk, and showing that it is usually actually easy to to?