Here's to hoping the indies will drag the industry forward with FPS' that aren't modern warfare retreads. Upcoming titles such as Hawken[1] give me some modicum of hope.
I'm surprised my favorite indie FPS of the past decade hasn't been mentioned here: Air Buccaneers. Basically it was was a UT2004 mod, an FPS where you can man hot air balloons airships with manually loaded/aimed old-style cannons. Being part of a good team of 2 or 3 on one of those things was a blast.
Seems they're updating it: http://www.airbuccaneers.com/
And if I'm honest, when you get past the fact it's Mechs, the gameplay looks a little dull to me.
The crux of the article is disappointment in the single player campaign.