Cell networks could improve infill coverage consistency with professional installs of roof mounted CPE. That would help people who have a weak signal inside their home but good signal outside.
Cell networks could improve infill coverage consistency with professional installs of roof mounted CPE. That would help people who have a weak signal inside their home but good signal outside.
The issue is economic. Target 1 customer per square mile and most of the orbit over land is useful, target 100,000 customers per square mile and most satellites are only beneficial over megacities like NYC.
Due to the short lifespan of individual satellites they can adjust to market forces and new technology fairly rapidly. If for example China lets them in the economics around density change significantly.
Spot size is one physics problem.
Antenna size is a different one. They're orbiting low enough that atmospheric effects become a real issue. See the deployment in February[1] where they lost ~40 of the 49 satellites in a launch batch, because a Geomagnetic storm increased the atmospheric density at their initial parking orbit, overwhelming the ability for their control system to maintain orbit.
So, yeah, they could then scale up the control system, too - but that makes them even heavier, increases fuel expenditure, reduces lifetime, etc.
[1] https://www.space.com/spacex-starlink-satellites-lost-geomag...
It increases mass, sure, but an increased mass to drag area ratio is usually considered a good thing (you'll be needing a better rocket to launch it tho).
This is why from the linked article:
> The satellites were then placed in a protective "safe mode" and commanded to fly edge-on "like a sheet of paper" to minimize drag effects as the company worked with the U.S. Space Force and the company LeoLabs to track them with ground-based radar, it added.
It seems that they are far safer once they have boosted up into operational orbit - that's why only the recently launched Starlinks fell back to earth.
This example is from the wikipedia article on directional antennas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directional_antenna#/media/Fil...
This is the standard way of showing the performance of antennas - it shows the varying amount of power that is sent out from the antenna in different directions. Note that (a) it doesn't roll off immediately outside the target zone (usually the 3dB threshold as shown here) and (b) there is measurable power in completely off-axis directions. In fact the tighter you beam steer, the more lobes you get in weird places.
Both of these mean that you can't just parcel up physical space into perfect beam spots and just keep adding satellites. There are all sorts of things you can do to help as you go up, but it gets harder and harder.
If you’re talking average 10km separation on the ground that would mean stupid high constilation densities. A lower densities it’s more meaningful.
PS: I got to 1 billion customers assuming different hardware and more satellites not just more satellites. The only way 100,000 customers “works” is a none viable and lower bandwidth per customer business model, but the goal was to illustrate a point. Space X is aiming for an economic sweet spot, not the outer edge of what’s technically possible.
Basically a network that handles 1 customer per square mile might in theory have say 40 million customers worldwide eventually. A network capable of handling 10 people per square mile might cost 10x as much, but only increase that to say 120 million because some areas have less than 10 potential customers per square mile. Increasing that to say 100 or even 100,000 people per square mile would vastly increase the cost, but you hit heavy diminishing returns with a lower percentage of areas reaching those densities and many people with better internet options than starlink or simply can’t afford the service.
So for each busy satellite you have 10 to 100 others on the same orbit which are still cruising over the ocean.
To maximize efficiency you want to have similar load wherever the satellite is.
You're entirely wrong here. Their customer density is way higher than 1 per square mile... I'm not even sure where you get these ideas.
Each cell is 146 miles, which is around 2 terminals per square mile.
People may be clustered a bit, giving the illusion of starlink being able to support a higher density than this.
Starlink isn't as scalable as people want to imagine due to the RF bandwidth SpaceX has as well as power requirements. This is part of why SpaceX made such a big deal over the 12GHz band that Dish wants to use.
The next version of satellites may be able to support additional bands which will help, but starlink's still going to be fairly limited in terms of number of people it can support.