Similar to when abortion was outlawed in the US and suddenly people cared a lot about all that Google Maps location history that Google was saving. It's much easier to convince people to mitigate a real problem than it is to prevent a hypothetical future problem. So convince them to mitigate this "real" problem that governments can see your dictionary queries, and hopefully that might prevent an actually real future problem.
What do think you know about "how totalitarian regimes operate"? Worked for some have you?
What we do know, from well sourced documents, is that real-time keyscore type filtering and flagging of every byte of unencrypted data occurs at ISPs, and that is common practice in our own non-totalitarian nations. What do you imagine goes on in less savoury dictatorships to whom we sell the same intercept equipment and DPI firewalls?
To describe that landscape as "cartoonish exaggeration" seems either naive or disingenuous.
Tell me you've never been in that situation without telling me you've never been in that situation. Check your privilege.
I was hauled in front of the police, and they went through my search history. I'm innocent and still thought I was going to get the chair.
Every little search is taken out of context and the worst intentions are assumed.
I honestly can't stand this kind of flippant attitude by people who've never experienced anything remotely like this. And now it's even worse for say American women looking for an abortion etc.
Or it's used as a trigger to engage in further observation of your web activities
One man's infosec advisory on attack vectors is another man's scaremongering. Hand waving around a problem does nothing to address it.
"How Google searches for 'pressure cookers' and 'backpacks' led the cops to a writer's door"
https://www.theverge.com/2013/8/1/4580654/michele-catalano-g...
June 30th: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-google-reverse-k...
> In documents filed Thursday in Denver District Court, lawyers for the 17-year-old argue that the police violated the Constitution when they got a judge to order Google to check its vast database of internet searches for users who typed in the address of a home before it was set ablaze on Aug. 5, 2020.
Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31938350