We are entering a new world of collective action
wyclif.substack.com
wyclif.substack.com
My God, I wish there were establishment figures pushing the unionization narrative but, on the contrary, workplace bargaining remains obscure and extremely unsupported by institutions. The workers I know who are organizing do not have "establishment" backing. It's hard even getting business unions to return phonecalls! Labor organizing is a massive, industrious undertaking that's NOT subsidized by established institutions but, rather, by the workers' families on our nights and weekends.
It's absurd to suggest that union efforts—misguided though you made consider them to be—are fueled by anything but the sweat of our own brow. It's flattering, though, that you think labor organizers have accomplished, independently, what appears, to you, heavily subsidized.
See campaign contributions to the Democratic Party by industry in the last election cycle:
https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/industries?cy...
Unions are fully embedded in the establishment, to the point that the only thing that kills them is the contraction/bankruptcy of the industry they colonize.
Look at Detroit: it was the richest city in America in 1950. Within 40 years of the UAW Union taking over the Big Three automakers (membership rose through the 50s and 60s, peaking in 1979), the big automakers have lost their market dominance, and Detroit is a shell of its former self.
No matter what the movement is, if it's large, then there will be some large corporations, governments, etc. behind it.
That doesn't mean it's fake or it's not grassroots or it's not real. It just means that it's big enough that the constituents of The Establishment (CEOs, elected officials, corporate workers, etc.) are joining it as well.
Just as if some shadow organisation is behind everything someone doesn't like.
The world is changing, people. Like it or not.
Most establishments are gaining power. Right-wing authoritarianism is taking over governments in the US, India, and Poland. We are in a new Gilded Age, where people like Elon Musk can openly commit crimes without punishment and Peter Thiel can select Senate candidates. The CCP is gaining power and big banks are buying up cryptocurrency.
The only failing establishment I know of is organized religion, and even then, Islam and Christian fundamentalism are doing just fine.
The supposed examples of grassroots level action are being organized/directed and inspired by people already in positions of influence in traditional establishments. That's not too surprising I suppose.
There's an unspoken implication here that'd I'll make explicit: the supposed goals of these movements are not the true motivations of the people most responsible for driving them. They serve the hidden interests of the groups pushing them first and foremost.