I’m sorry you don’t feel your particular pet peeve is being addressed on day zero and I’m doubly sorry to see such a negative attitude toward a clearly constructive initiative.
Not every single issue will be solved immediately or perfectly.
This is about turning a huge ship around - and changing whole industries in the process.
Once they change for Europe, the rest of the world is more likely to change, too.
I'd expect housing, healthcare, education, food, clothing, and transport to be bigger.
Anecdotally, I spend more on optical care and on fresh apples and oranges than I do on smartphones most years. Clothing, much more. Housing costs, orders of magnitude more.
Or did you mean "confining ourselves to goods with semiconductors in them"? Then cars are a bigger market. Probably kitchen appliances too.
No, there are not more people in the world that have cars than have mobile phones.
Right to repair and android manufacturers being shit are 2 separate issues. And fixing one of those issues is worth it on its own.
This would be a win even if they excluded smartphones completely.
Not sure what your problem is exactly. You are all ower this thread arguing with everyone. But other the smartphones not being updated, which doe not have much to do with right to repair in first place, you haven't really said really made any argument.
What good is the “right to repair” the most ubiquitous device people own if it isn’t getting security updates? I don’t have to worry about my kitchen devices being secure and most of them cost less than $100. There has never been an issue with refrigerators or washers being relatively easy to repair or even TVs for that matter.
My 65 inch TV costs less than my phone.
None of the other devices you mention have parts that always wear out like smartphone batteries.
Phones are essential in even third world countries. None of the other things you are mentioning are.
It’s the typical EU lawmakers who passed a 11 chapter 99 section law that made the web worse with nothing more to show for it but cookie pop up banners.
And is important for smartphones too. What good are security updates for old phones if they have busted screen or battery that wont charge anymore.
> And there are a lot more people who own phones than cars or washing machines.
So what, doesn't mean it's still not relevant. Cars being the big issue, where repairs often cost more than most phones.
> How many washing machines does the average family have compared to phones?
Again so what, it's still an issue. And if you count dishwashers, microwaves refrigerators, coffeemakers, toasters, ovens, tv's, radios etc.
Average family has more of them than phones and they combined, often cost more than phones. Remember majority of people don't own flagships but cheap phones.
> What good is the “right to repair” the most ubiquitous device people own if it isn’t getting security updates?
What good are security updates for old phones if they have busted screens or battery that wont charge anymore.
Besides Right to repair would be worth it even if it explicitly left of smartphones. But it doesn't.
> There has never been an issue with refrigerators or washers being relatively easy to repair or even TVs for that matter.
That is changing. Even Mile appliances that cost a lot more than 100 bucks are hard to repair and often have to replace.
> My 65 inch TV costs less than my phone.
Majority of people in my country have phones that cost less than 200 EUR. Most decent TV's cost more than that.
> None of the other devices you mention have parts that always wear out like smartphone batteries.
Pretty much everything except TV's have parts that wears out, even if it's just the hinges and seals. but the thing that most often craps out is electronics. Source my brother works for Mile distributer in our country.
> Phones are essential in even third world countries. None of the other things you are mentioning are.
People in 3rd world countries rely on cooking much more than people in developed countries.
And you can always buy cheap feature phones, that last almost forever and can change batteries and have small attack surface.
> It’s the typical EU
They are at leas doing something. Unlike American lawmakers that just lube their assholes and bend over to the corporations.
- most users currently don’t get support, so idk what you’re arguing for here
- you already have to rely on countless 3rd parties in order to use your phone
So if that is cause it’s just an old device and new feature don’t have what they need. But others is a decision they make.
Look at the recent redesign of the Reminders app, the fact that the new and old version are incompatible is not because of hardware. Nor is their choice to not backport it.
Can you say the same about an Android device from 2013?
The 5s was the first 64 bit iPhone.
But why should the phones have to stop getting security updates? Both apple and android manufacturers will abandon those phones at some point. (And security updates are different from feature parity) why should those devices be condemned simply because the manufacturers cannot be bothered.
Why should I not be able to update my device simply because the manufacturer can no longer be bothered to do it themselves?
Going to an Apple store or authorized dealer isn’t as big of a deal to get a $69 battery replacement as it is to ask an Android user to hunt the internet to hopefully find a community supported Android variant that still supports their phone and still not have access to Google Play Services .
Even Google once had to drop support for some Nexus devices because it couldn’t convince chipset makers to support their latest OS on the phone.
We have tons of products and services with a TOS stating things like service is not guaranteed, we are not responsible for damages etc Line by line they make the product more terrible because they have good reason to, any kind of support costs money and no one reads the TOS.
If we could however express each of those terms into 2-5 numbers on a score card it would all of a sudden become interesting for the manufacturer to review those.
Who knows? Maybe if one of our widgets explodes we should pay up to 1000 dollar worth of damages if it means 10 points in responsibility in stead of -100
If replacement parts or even upgrades makes our brand stick out head and shoulders above the competition in official ratings then we should at least have someone do a powerpoint about it, perhaps even a spreadsheet.
Scores for existing devices can be improved later. Lowering them could involve fines and/or compensation.
Perhaps there is even some market logic to be had: Perhaps if one is stuck with a low score one should pick cheaper parts that have a similar score in stead of bragging about how awesome some components are. I must have purchased more than 50 iphone chargers by now. The expensive ones break just as fast as the cheap ones. Apple should get lots of points for all the parts of their show they got right but also -1000 for the charger quality. Some of the unofficial ones should probably be rated -5000 which is fine if it costs 5 euro. Even if it costs 20 euro I shouldn't be complaining if durability was rated -5000?
Except the EU pulled that one off already. When you have one of the biggest markets in the world and the ability to levy high fines, you can make companies do all sorts of things.
If somebody followed you around in real life, watching your every move, would you not consider it a win if he asked you if that makes you feel uncomfortable and they should stop?
Would you consider it a worse experience than them just continuing to follow you, unasked?
Harm reduction still happens with non-perfect scenarios.