Carmack rewriting Doom 3 source code to dodge legal issues
vg247.com
vg247.com
Source: https://twitter.com/#!/ID_AA_Carmack/status/1371892125197926...
If basic information theory can be patented, there's a problem.
Some of Carmacks comments at the time seemed to say that Creative were using their patent to strong arm him into adding support for their hardware into Doom3.
There was also a lot of discussion about whether the patent was reasonable at the time, including, as stated on Slashdot, a claim that Sim Dietrich from Nvidia had demo'd the technique publicly, months before the patent was filed.
Some interesting comments here: http://games.slashdot.org/story/04/07/28/1529222/creative-pr...
In particular, the comment by 'Dan East' in 2004 wondering if it'll affect the ability of iD to release source, is pretty prophetic!
Until recently, the US was "first to invent", not first to file, and public disclosure didn't establish a bar date but rather started a count-down to a bar date. In other words, a public disclosure a few months before a filing can be irrelevant. Whether it actually is irrelevant depends on some other details.
Just because something is badass and awesome doesn't mean it should be patented.
Software patents are ridiculous, but not because (or only if) they're trivial.
I don't think it's necessary to deify Carmack, either. He is an extraordinary programmer, but he is not super-human.
Carmack would qualify as 'an engineer sufficiently skilled in the art'. That he's one of the most skilled wouldn't be relevant.
I used this algorithm just the other day in some exercise work for uni studies. We actually had this algorithm as an example on one of the basic 3d graphics courses.
When the d3 source is out, I might take the time to re-write the z-fail shadow volume code to doom3 and push it to a git server hosted in a country with sane patent laws. If I have very much time on my hands, I might try to do the shadow volume extrusion on the GPU with geometry shaders (a post-doom3 addition to GPU pipeline).
The patent http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=Om0LAAAAEBAJ&dq=6...
Ideas are the only thing that can be patented....
More specifically not the general idea of trapping mice, but the general idea of a hinge and a spring, or the use of cheese on a trigger, or whatever, as general as you can get it.
Your hypothetical patent would for example not cover a mousetrap that uses a box with the cheese at the bottom and a rod over it that the mouse will fall off if it goes out to try to stretch for the cheese, unless that is explicitly covered in separate claims. So it does not cover the general idea of a mousetrap but of the specific method of catching mice with a spring loaded trap.
(the method I described above works, very well, assuming the sides are slippery/smooth enough for the mouse to be unable to climb them) - my dad tried catching a mouse alive when I was a kid to show me; he tried 4-5 times, and it caught a mouse each time, but all of them were dead when we found them - we never figured out if it was from the very limited fall or from the shock or what it was).
Otherwise known as an idea.
Mouse walks up stick, sees/smells bait and jumps into box to eat it. Box is too high (about 14" tall) for mouse to jump back out. No, I did not patent this mousetrap!
I tossed the mice to my chickens. The ones that got away were lucky; the rest... well let's just say my chickens lay some mighty tasty eggs :-)
I have both hardware and software patents. They're exactly the same.
"Programming languages" are in reality nothing more than fancy mathematical notations. Conversion to more traditional notations, such as lambda calculus, is so trivial that any computer science undergrad can do it.
To put it bluntly, algorithms are no less math than the Pythagorean Theorem.
I strongly disagree. Consider an event-driven presentation and interface layer over a database backend: a very common bit of software. You can't even explain that meaningfully in terms of math, let alone say it is math.
Some software has good math-based explanations, but lots of it doesn't. Saying software is math is rather like saying it's all ones and zeros. True in a weak sense, but it doesn't capture much that is meaningful. Often, a piece of software is better understood as a machine, which is a traditional domain of patents.
edit: I dislike software patents because they are often granted on stupid things in practice. This is probably due to abuse of the system by applicants, which is a response to the lack of expertise and bad previous judgement by the patent office, which seems to invite such abuse.
edit 2: the software patent situation is very hard to change now, since Big Software lobbies very hard to prevent that.
But software isn't math.
> You can't even explain that meaningfully in terms of math
Oh yes you can. You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex, very quickly, but it can be done, as the Church-Turing thesis (recursion, lambda-calculus, and Turing machines are equivalent) is mathematically proven. And people do actually use that to formally prove correctness of software[2].
[0] http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20110908075658894
[1] http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20111005102810...
[2] http://www.theengineer.co.uk/news/safer-software/312631.arti...
Computer science is math, maybe.
No, you can't. Proving the correctness of a word processor has almost nothing to do with the design of its functionality. What should a word processor do? The answer to that question is not math. Does this piece of code do what this written specification says it should do? The answer to that question can be produced by math. Software is at least both of these things. It certainly is not math alone.
> You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex, very quickly
That's an ad hominen in front of an irrelevant statement. The Church-Turing thesis is indeed proven. A simple statement of that thesis goes: "Everything algorithmically computable is computable by a Turing machine. Some things are not thus computable." This idea along its proof, is one of the finest human achievements of the twentieth century. But it sure doesn't tell you how to write a word processor. It tells you that the word processor you wrote could be run on any of a family of equivalent machines, and that it can't compute certain things. That's deep and lovely indeed. Since that proof was created, we knew that Visicalc, Word, TeX and Bit Torrent existed in the space of possible programs, and by implication we knew a lot about their properties. Somebody still had to design and write the fuckers, and they were not doing math when they did so. They were engineering software.
Another completely different angle: If you admit that "The Mythical Man Month" was any kind of contribution to software, can you explain its contribution to mathematics?
> You just lack the tools and understanding for it, and it can get very complex
I think I'll put this on a t-shirt. Thanks.
No it's not. That may have once been the ideal but has never been the case.
Yes, patent law is that ridiculous.