Will pharmacists do this now? Or are patients still expected to bring over the counter hearing aids to audiologists for those adjustments?
Will pharmacists do this now? Or are patients still expected to bring over the counter hearing aids to audiologists for those adjustments?
"A central problem of hearing aid fitting is that the space of gain-frequency responses that can be achieved with digital hearing aids is extremely large, but only a subset of those responses could reasonably be audiologically appropriate for any particular ear. Client-based selection of amplification has historically involved some combination of restricting the number of individual gain-frequency responses available (e.g., Humes et al., 2017) and providing efficient methods for navigating the space of gain-frequency responses (e.g., Sabin et al., 2020). The approach of offering a choice between three presets was found to be efficacious in clinical trials of a client-driven delivery model (Humes et al., 2017, 2019). Recent work suggests that as few as four gain-frequency responses can provide audiologically appropriate fits to 60%–75% of adults with mild-to-moderate sensorineural loss (Jensen et al., 2020; Urbanski et al., 2021). Greater coverage can be achieved by expanding the number of gain-frequency responses available to the wearer (Sabin et al., 2021). In a field trial of a self-adjustment tool that provided clients with a large range of gain-frequency responses, participants showed slight preferences for self-adjusted settings over clinician-fit settings, and no group-level differences in clinical measures of amplification benefit were observed (Sabin et al., 2020)."
Perry, T. T., & Nelson, P. B. (2022). Self-Adjustment of Hearing Aid Amplification for Lower Speech Levels: Independent Ratings, Paired Comparisons, and Speech Recognition. American Journal of Audiology, 1-17.
TL;DR: Some products will come with 4 or 5 presets that you can choose between and then tweak slightly. Some products will come with software (such as a smartphone app) that includes simplified (yet effective!) user interfaces for the wearer to self-adjust the amplification. Some products will ask you to engage in a computerized hearing test to set the device to levels prescribed by an audiogram-based fitting prescription formula. We will see many more audiologists and hearing instrument specialists modifying their service delivery models to invite people to bring their already-purchased OTC hearing aids in and have them programmed by a specialist.
I'm not an expert here but the small amount of digging I've done suggests the opposite. You can permanently damage your hearing if you tune the hearing aid wrong, and it's extremely fiddly (can take many sessions with a professional audiologist) to get things right.
I think this is still compatible with some adjustments being done on an app, and definitely with some set of "safe parameters" being available without prescriptions. I just want to push back a bit on the idea that what an audiologist is doing is trivial. I expect most people with severe hearing loss will still want to see a specialist. But _as long as the risks are understood_, more choices are better than fewer.
Real-time feedback and control goes a long way to turn a (potentially embarrassing or shameful) disability into something simple, empowering, and even fun.
It should also be noted that a huge problem in countries in Europe where hearing aids are subsidized by the state is getting people to actually use their subscribed hearing aids. Usually the patients needs information and coaching to be motivated. With that in mind I think alot of over the counter hearing aids will just end up in a shelf somewhere if there isn't any good resource for encouragement and technical help.
Do you know how people feel about their hearing aids?
Where do you see the industry going in 5-10 years?
What companies in the space look promising/exciting to you?
I used EarMachine [ https://apps.apple.com/us/app/earmachine/id732177210 ] with custom hardware in my studies. The amplification controls consist of two touchscreen wheels, one which increases the gain (with a higher rate of increase in high frequencies than in the low frequencies) and one which acts as a spectral tilt. There is a complex mapping from the two wheels to the gain, but that's the simplification. It's just traditional non-linear amplification that is applied to the input signal.
Industry labs are privately exploring all sorts of things, but they won't share publicly until their products are ready for market. The NIH has been funding the development of "open master hearing aids/simulators" to promote research into new signal processing strategies, and start-ups are pursuing new delivery models. A lot could change in just the next 2 years.
>Do you know how people feel about their hearing aids?
Every so often some market research data is published under the name MarkeTrak [ https://betterhearing.org/policy-research/marketrak/ ]. This summary is most relevant [ https://www.audiologyonline.com/articles/20q-understanding-t... ]. About 2/3rds of people who could benefit from hearing aids do not own/use them. There are a lot of reasons for that, and actual satisfaction with hearing aids is only a part. In the UK where there's no financial barrier to getting hearing aids for the vast majority of people, hearing aid adoption rates are low. Culture, social stigma, and even personality plays a huge role in how people feel about hearing aids. That's the background for this: Most hearing aid owners are satisfied. People who have hearing aids older than 6 years tend to be less satisfied than people who have new hearing aids.
>Where do you see the industry going in 5-10 years?
Broadly speaking, I expect to see a lot of experimentation and diversity in products and service delivery models. Using the principle of "the more things change, the more things stay the same", I would predict that we will see an increased focus on products and delivery models that feature greater personalization and greater integration with consumer electronics. I think we're gonna see an attempt to leverage more and different sensors on the body to modify and control device output. I think we might see some breakthroughs on noise reduction algorithms, but in the end they won't prove as useful as we'd hoped. I think Zuckerberg wants to sell a VR headset to every grandparent and great-grandparent.
>What companies in the space look promising/exciting to you?
You know I just don't have a good answer for this one. Very sorry!