I think you already know you got scammed. The guy couldn't care if it was new printer or not. He was just scamming you and sending those messages just to test you and may be prove to their banks that you didn't give them what you promised.
We need someone to disrupt this monopoly that these banks have where most disputes are won by consumers and not business owners. We had a guy use our SAAS for 6+ months and then charged back everything because he claimed it was "defective product" as per Stripe and we lost that dispute. Funny he raised tons of support tickets in the meantime but right at 6 months decided to take it all back (He knew what he was doing because I believe you can go back upto 6 months usually for chargebacks).
Coming back to you, you absolutely were scammed. Question is: Does Ebay care ? My guess: Not.