I like you drew, and I pay for your products. I make this post with a sincere face, please do the moves that got you to the dance.
I like you drew, and I pay for your products. I make this post with a sincere face, please do the moves that got you to the dance.
I have been aware of these developments for a long time, as many PINE64 community members are among my personal friends and collaborators. I had hoped that pressure from others would be enough to bring about change, but seeing PINE64's response to Martijn's post confirmed that it's not. I'm here to do my part in keeping the pressure on PINE64 to do the right thing.
I blog often, and most of my blog posts are not critical in tone. However, critical ones tend to receive more coverage in places like HN. If you'd like to see more diverse writing from me, I encourage you to subscribe to my RSS feed.
Does that incentivize an author to be more dramatic? At least in your case, you blog without the exclusive intention of reaching front pages. But it's interesting to always note the "outrage" incentive exists.
I don't see anything wrong with that. It seems to be the right thing to do. The alternative is deleting the posts so people don't get mislead by him recommending PINE64 even though he maybe wouldn't anymore at the current point in time.
I hope they'll reach out to Martjin and that they find a way to come to an understanding.
no matter how we twist and turn, this kind of fighting is not helpful. drew may be right in what he says, but being right doesn't matter. collaboration, support and good will matter. if we want to help a project that is making mistakes, they need to be able to fix those mistakes without being denounced.
as drew says, it’s difficult to acknowledge our mistakes, and exactly because of that, we as a community need to create an environment where acknowledging mistakes is possible without embarrassment. those asked to acknowledge their mistakes need to be sure that they will be forgiven. unfortunately, with both pine64 and manjaro seemingly being pushed into a corner, i don't know if that can happen.
drew is exactly right when he describes the three outcomes, where the only successful outcome will be for pine64 to acknowledge their mistake with grace and humility.
but, this is going to be very difficult if everyone keep putting pressure in them, because for sure there will be some who will not recognize if pine64 responded with grace and humility. instead everyone else needs to deal with this problem with equal grace and humility too.
those with a stake in this situation need to get around a (virtual) table, and work this out amongst themselves, and come up with steps to move forward where everyone of them can get something positive out of it. it may be difficult, but i really wish that this is going to happen. (my son is waiting for that pinetime i ordered, and the pinephone with the external keyboard is still on my shoppinglist as my next portable server and emergency laptop, so really i am rooting for their success)
Mobile FOSS is important. He has a position where a simple blog post by him can reach the HN front pages. It's a good thing that he's putting his opinion out there in a constructive fashion to help prevent mobile FOSS from decaying.
It would be one thing if he went all Twitter and started telling everyone to leave Pine otherwise they would be morally equivalent to Hitler.
That's not what he did. He has pointed out several alternative steps Pine can take and what he believes the outcome would be, while also pointing out a simple constructive step that he believes would help remedy not just this specific situation, but long term, perhaps irreparable, damage to mobile FOSS.
This comes across as an unambiguously good post to me.
It's clear there's a lot of he-said she-said, with some truths mixed in, but what's clear is that the two sides are different paths in the road to the same destination. It's sad that we can't make it to the finish line as a team, but that's life, and that's okay.
I don't think so. It all reads that "Hey, Pine64, You're ruining it. Get it together or you'll be in a worse shape".
With his prominence around certain circles, he's just making the situation tougher for Pine64, by making things even more visible, and I support that.