My only issue with doing the full-on module pattern is that, coming from a Python/Ruby background, I've stopped caring about the notion of private vs protected vs public, especially when considering testing. In other languages (like Java) I can add a dash of reflection magic in my unit-tests to get to hidden components, but that seems to be impossible using Javascript's module pattern. Take this snippet for example:
var Module = (function() {
var baz;
function foo(x) {
baz = x;
}
return {
bar: function() {
foo(42);
}
};
})();
There are several variations of the pattern, but that's the basic gist of it. Once it becomes non-trivial, how do I test foo? How do I verify baz's state? Furthermore, if I wanted to extend this with one of Javascript's sub-class implementations, how would my new slightly-different "bar" be able to use "foo"?Besides my general opinion of private variables and methods being unnecessary, unless someone has a good fix for those two problems, I'll never consider using the module pattern in any code that I write.