Hacker News Reader

Comment by inglor_cz | Hacker News Reader

Pardon me, but why have modern binaries grown so big? When I wrote my thesis in TeX, the entire installation would fit in some 30 megabytes or so. It was actually right in the uncomfortable middle. Far too big to carry around on a set of diskettes, but a CD would be waste of space.

View on HN

You can fit a decent TeX distribution in <100MB.

But if you want to have every macro package that everyone everywhere likes, you're going to use some space.

I've often wondered why there isn't a dependency system for TeX that lets you get only the packages you need... feed it a document and tell it to automatically download and install any missing packages.

There may be some technical reason why this isn't practical. Anyone know, offhand?

Totally practical and supported. See MikTeX: https://miktex.org/kb/just-enough-tex

But the reason I don't use it is because I don't always have Internet when I need to write my document. I'd rather download all the packages and their documentation beforehand.

MikTeX also supports downloading individual packages, though I wish there was an option to download, say, the most commonly used 1GB or something.

When stuck on a plane without wifi the only thing I could find on my computer to read were the Tex manuals. Good stuff.

There is a TeX distribution that does what you say, TinyTeX. For some reason it is obscure and only really used by R and R Studio users. That may be because it is used to render R Markdown documents to pdf.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com