I use a combination of incoming links and the average ranking of these linking sites to add new sites to the crawl queue. It's not super sophisticated, and I think it matters less the bigger the crawl is.
Some still slip by, but the ranking algorithm takes care of the rest. I'm using personalized pagerank[1] biased toward a set of real human websites, which turns out to rather aggressively promote human websites.
[1] http://ilpubs.stanford.edu:8090/422/1/1999-66.pdf (see ch. 6)