Hacker News Reader

Comment by kyrofa | Hacker News Reader

I dunno, pointing out that something has a poor architecture and pointing out that something has severe, known, and ignored security issues feels different.

View on HN

Availability is the A in the CIA triad. DR and resilience in general is part of security.

That's never actually the case in an org chart, though. A CISO may require that a DR plan exists, but they're not the ones in charge of implementing it.

Also, if they can handle a primary datacenter outage, they have a working DR plan. If I was working on an infrastructure team and was told I needed to handle multiple, simultaneous datacenter outages, I'd start looking for another job.

Knocking-out twitter (used by journalists and govs) during a crisis IS a security concern.

A security concern for the governments, not twitter. It's not twitter's fault that governments are using it as a primary form of communication, nor should it be their responsibility to have amazing uptime just because governments are using their platform.

It's a national security concern (and international?) if Twitter can be compromised by nefarious actors and/or brought down via said compromised access. The idea that this isn't worthy of whistleblowing because Twitter is a corporation is insane. There are countless examples in the last year of Twitter being used for communication during a crisis.

That's ridiculous. If I created a service and the government happened to start using it, my service being taken down should not be labeled a national security issue against me. The national security issue would be the government deciding to rely on my service.

For all the first amendment protectors out there - the government forcing a private company to comply with some mythical security / uptime standard so it can propagandise its population - that is an actual violation.

Ludicrous, but this is the situation... holy cow, imagine a future where TikTok likes, determine the outcome of an election.

You can watch it live in 2024, when all of social media has morphed into TikTok clones.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com