I think a language needs to decide if it is "high level" or if it is instead a convenience language on top of assembly.
BASIC and Pascal I am sure would have been considered a high-level language in their day and naturally would have arrays be 1-based.
C on the other hand....
Except VB.NET which is only 0-based but you can just shut your eyes and imagine it's 1-based because you declare an array by specifying its upper bound which equals its number of elements in 1-based.
Pascal is a variant of ALGOL-60, made in part because Wirth thought ALGOL-68 was way too complicated. BASIC instead comes from the FORTRAN line.