I also presume manual transmissions will continue to be available to the enthusiasts and professionals/sportspeople who have an actual reason to desire them.
I also presume manual transmissions will continue to be available to the enthusiasts and professionals/sportspeople who have an actual reason to desire them.
it's very fun to row through the gears of a moderately sporty car; that's where people's "fetishm" (more accurately "preference") comes from
My tiny ultra-efficient EV blows them both out of the water on mountain roads though.
There's one exception: the RWD EV's front end likes to skid while decelerating into turns. I prefer the Mustang's habit of breaking the rear end loose while accelerating out of turns.
I'm on board with it being a hybrid (though it actually gets roughly the same fuel economy on the highway) and especially happy with gas prices what they are now. But I don't think you need a sporty car to appreciate the torque you generate in a manual
Fast-forward to today, and it's all changed. Automatics have at least as many gears, they're more reliable (they don't need the clutch changed every 100-200k), and they have significantly better fuel economy. The only reason to drive a manual now is basically nostalgia.
Where I live (where manuals are the "default") it seems like automatics are the fetishistic option. There's lots of hills, winding country roads etc round here, an automatic is a bloody nightmare because it doesn't "know" I'm approaching a hill, time to drop to a lower gear just here, I'm approaching the top of a hill, change up now, I'm overtaking on a road, I need high acceleration now. It completely fails at knowing all this and is less efficient as a result.
This is why I am sceptical of all the "automatics are more efficient these days" line. Maybe there's some volkswagen style dodgy tests that show that driving under predictable conditions on a motorway it is more efficient, but as automatics can't know upcoming conditions on the road or intentions I doubt they are more efficient in the real world. At least not round here.
I've owned a dozen+ manual transmissions and the one in my Hyundai Elantra is by far the worst I have ever used. It's incredible "notchy" and prevents you from shifting between gears quickly (I assume intentionally for fuel economy/longevity reasons). You couldn't pick a worse example to compare against.
Well, that explains. You haven’t had a fun manual car. I loved my e36 325. Porsche 964 was nice, too.
I’m also pretty positive if you wanted to buy a brand new Porsche or BMW you could pay for a manual version.
> Manual transmission fetishism is perplexing to me. I’ve owned two manual transmission cars… an old Hyundai Elantra and an even older Toyota pickup. I can’t think of a single reason I would not rather have the automatic version of either.
To which I say: it’s because you haven’t had a fun manual car. BMW 325i and Porsche 964 were both fun in manual.
> I’m also pretty positive if you wanted to buy a brand new Porsche or BMW you could pay for a manual version.
No, actually it doesn’t work like this anymore for most new models.