In the article they mention that Dijon mustard made in France is now made in the neighboring subdivision and therefore would violate a hypothetical AOS/AOP.
Yes, the specific taste can be specific to the region’s produce or historic process but that’s true of anything if you’re willing to mythologize it. You shouldn’t be able to claim it made where it isn’t but Dijon mustard meaning “mustard made in the style as popularized in the town of Dijon” is not something you get to claim geographic dominion over long long long after it’s been the genericized accepted term for the specific food. Dijon is a kind of Spicy Mustard but the implication doesn’t go backwards and there’s no other name for it.
Hamburg is not the origin of hamburgers --at least it's rather contested, Frankfurters on the other hand...
That said, Buffalo wings are best in Buffalo. And keep in mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffal...
I don't agree, when I shed some money on champagne or balsamic vinegar, I want to be sure to have the real deal and not a bland commercial copy surfing on prestigious name. AOP labels ensure that I am getting the real product I'm looking for. I've been in Russia and tasted their Cognac and Champagne, it's nowhere close the french stuff and they know it. It really taste different.
"hoover" might have become a household name, but does that allow anyone to slap a "hoover" name on their vacuum cleaner?
Specific brands can have all the trademark protection they want. Defining buffalo wings as wings made in Buffalo and only using chickens raised and slaughtered there is silly.
The fact that the US didn't initially sign these treaties and allowed people to sell fake Champagne to their consumers for so long doesn't really change that
Oh, dear, balsamic vinegar.
I would like to taste real balsamic vinegar. It's cause for regret that there are two kinds of Balsamic Vinegar of Modena: stuff for cooking, and stuff for sipping, both of which have protected designations. The stuff for cooking is basically fake, containing stuff like caramel, and costs a tenner a bottle. The stuff for sipping costs £200 for a pint, and takes 12 years to make.
I'd like to know where I could buy just a snifter of the stuff, to taste.