Hacker News Reader

Comment by vineyardmike | Hacker News Reader

They could put-compete if they can create an iPhone with extra powerful antennas or other hardware. Like they always do- own the full stack to allow it to work better.

View on HN

you can't create "extra powerful antennas" in a cell phone. it's physics, and antenna gain is driven by size.

And then you need to design it in a way that it’s not blocked by somebody’s hand when they hold the phone.

Or just add a telescopic antenna and present it as "innovation never seen before".

What?! You mean, have an antenna show outside a phone, like in the pre-2010s? In today's world, form is more important than function.

Especially for fashion statements like iphones. (Doubt this? Upthread people are discussing how certain affluent neighbourhoods only have iphones).

It was somewhat off the cuff and meant to encapsulate the idea that you can improve the ability of the phone to connect with the satellite. That isn’t possible if you don’t design the phone.

You could potentially control the situation enough where a user can enable “satellite mode” which uses extra power for sending messages. It’d affect battery life, and need to be manually enabled, but it’d enable better connections in emergencies.

You could try to improve directional antennas and some sort of aiming system with the screen.

Lots of things that maybe could happen when you control the client side instead of just the satellite side.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com