So the question of the origin is ill-posed. Yet there has to be an origin because an infinite history makes no sense.
In the end, nothing makes sense. God must be laughing at us.
So the question of the origin is ill-posed. Yet there has to be an origin because an infinite history makes no sense.
In the end, nothing makes sense. God must be laughing at us.
> Yet there has to be an origin because an infinite history makes no sense.
The origin has infinite history.
> God must be laughing at us.
No, because God is, like us, the descendant of something else, or else has infinite history.
What if the history is cyclic? Then there is no origin.
God could have no beginning. This makes sense because God exists outside of our conception of spacetime. We have to have a beginning, because in the universe we live in the laws of time and nature say everything has to have a beginning.
Maybe we’ll eventually figure out that when something passes through a singularities event horizon, that is the superheated ‘all energy’ state the universe was/is/has always been born from.
It wouldn’t be the weirdest thing that’s happened!
2) 'nature say everything has to have a beginning' uh?? If you imagine the Universe expanding then contracting cyclically where is the beginning?
I think mathematical statements don't have causes but constraints. Could be that the universe is somehow constrained to exist because of some incredibly abstract truth.
But what started the cycle?
I guess we as humans are the ones at fault here, because we can't accept something infinite as an answer in the real physical world.
> But what started the cycle?
It's a bit like asking where is the beginning of a circle, it doesn't make sense..
But it does have a beginning, you had to pickup a pencil, placed the carbon tip on the surface of the paper and then finally you were able to draw a circle.
So yes, it makes sense _before_ the circle even existed. Something created the circle, it didn't materializa itself out of nothing.
Yes, it does. It's just an uncomfortable notion for people raised in Western philosophy.