To be clear, I'm trying to explore the idea that individual songs have optimal tunings because they only use certain intervals. So, something more fine grained even then singing for a particular key.
To be clear, I'm trying to explore the idea that individual songs have optimal tunings because they only use certain intervals. So, something more fine grained even then singing for a particular key.
So the compromise we've all settled on is that we play music in the equitempered scale, and only adjust a little bit here and there to exploit perfect tunings in limited, style-dependent ways.
Which is to say: perfect chords are interesting flavor, but at the end of the day kinda boring in isolation; "real" music needs more rules.
(This is also the same mechanism at work when an entire choir singing an unaccompanied piece goes flat without realizing it. Someone will not quite make an ascending interval, and everyone else will adjust to cover it.)