As a former Catholic, subscription authentication is not strict. It's also apparently not difficult to get admin privileges — one of the priests teaching at my tiny high school was gay, and the pastors of both churches in my small midwestern town were eventually discovered to have been uncomfortably handy with children.
In the faith, the joke is that all Catholics are "à la carte Catholics" to some degree or another. Many will even dismiss papal ex-cathedra statements that they don't like, even though papal infallibility is Catholic dogma.