Expensive lifestyles like living in a region of the US that is more expensive than other regions?
I don't think it's unreasonable to occasionally take actions that would benefit the middle class.
Expensive lifestyles like living in a region of the US that is more expensive than other regions?
I don't think it's unreasonable to occasionally take actions that would benefit the middle class.
It’s regressive and does nothing to stop tuition and housing inflation.
One similar example would be people without kids still having their taxes go towards funding public education.
Because we want to prioritize overall education across the country.
You could argue one reason loans have become so prevalent is a failure of the government to properly subsidize and provide for higher levels of education for citizens.
Colleges will continue increasing tuition and pumping out worthless degrees. People will continue to rack up student loan debt. It’s just not sustainable.
Plumbers could have loans, they could have children with loans etc
The fact of the matter is most Americans do not have a college degree. You can perform all the mental gymnastics you want but at the end of the day, it’s a direct subsidy to the upper class.
Perhaps you are the one lacking awareness and maybe you should read the article.
Calling degree holders "upper class" is simply a way to keep the working class fighting within itself instead of working to change the system to be better for workers.
We’re spending hundreds of billions of debt relief here. That money could’ve gone towards medical debt, affordable housing, welfare expansion…etc.
Instead a one time payment is going out to college graduates without tackling core issues like inability to refinance, or skyrocketing tuition.
And again, tuition prices become inflated because of all these artificial federally guaranteed loans.
This isn’t about helping workers…it’s about winning votes. Neither party gives a shit about the working class.
Capital owners want us to be angry about things like this because it prevents progress for workers. Nearly everyone who has a degree is a worker. Instead of being angry about how the system fundamentally operates in favor of those who own capital, we squabble over crap like this.
I'm not saying there isn't a problem with tuition costs, there absolutely is
It seems I just have a wider definition of “capital holders” than you do.
For example there’s tons of subsidies to the upper middle class that I think should be eliminated. Examples are mortgage interest deductions, homestead exceptions, property tax deductions, long term capital gains…etc.
In my book the recent student debt forgiveness is just like those other things, although I admit they’re not as egregious as the carried interest rule, which was preserved in the inflation reduction act by lobbying efforts.
For the most part I agree with your point that our system is setup to benefit asset owners. It’s awful and needs to be stopped (even if I’m a beneficiary and take full advantage)
A FAANG engineer who makes 300k in salary and owns millions in securities and real estate is absolutely still a “capital owner” or upper class or whatever you wanna call it. The presence of a salary does not preclude someone from owning capital.
The basis for almost everyone’s retirement is US equities and property.
That is the differentiating factor. People can move into being capital owners sure, but it is extremely rare
If someone can quit their job and survive off of capital gains while not being homeless, they would be considered a capital owner
My 65 year old father maxed out his 401k for 35 years working his ass off. He's also set to receive a government pension from ~15 years working in the public sector. When he retires in a few years, would you lump him into this elite ruling class of "capital owner"?
He will be indeed living off capital gains without a salary. He will certainly not be homeless and even lives in a nice home. I truly cannot understand how someone in that position is supposed to be the enemy of American workers...