Imagine how awful that would be.
> ~2000 charges of ~20 years
And that makes me wonder. Maybe that would be too harsh a sentence then. Do we want to basically "end" someone's life at an insane cost to the tax payer for something with no impact on others other than financial? I have no answer, it just feels somewhat suboptimal to me.
If you steal a billion dollars from a whole bunch of middle class folks, you are, in aggregate "ending" a whole lot of life in small amounts distributed across many people.
I just feel like the aggregate punishment does not at all fit the crime in a case like this.
A problem with money is that it abstracts away harm so that a person stops thinking like it's so bad to take money away from people because it's just money, when in fact you're actually taking away the things people can do with that money.
Did zero people end up homeless as a result of this fraud? Did zero people lose a job? Did zero people turn to crime to get by? Did zero people get pushed over the edge to suicide? How many years of life were lost due to stress or more difficult life situations? To depression? To hunger?
I doubt any of those numbers are zero. The stories are just hidden behind the abstraction of money.
Crypto companies preying on gullible people more vulnerable to the loss of large sums of money and then losing their money due to management incompetence and fraud are indeed responsible for a lot of real world harm.
But what we have here is essentially somebody leading a bank taking all the money left after losing a bunch of it to hacks and running away with it. Whatever it was, it was an enormous amount of money and not the kind of thing anyone needs to be particularly forgiving about.
Life in prison for stealing between $20MM and $125MM from customers isn't out of the question. (on top of the fraud that lost them the rest of their money)
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impalement#Ottoman_Empire
If you're comfortable with prosecutors being able to play games with people's lives because they've made a personal judgment call to maximize their ability to punish people, great! The system is working the way you want it to.
Not everyone is comfortable with that.
That said, I think most property crime is motivated by desperation, and prison rarely does anything to help improve the lives of someone who only resorted to anti-social behavior because they had little other choice. So I think most robbery should only be punished because of the violent aspect, and most burglary should be "punished" with halfway houses or a system like the Civilian Conservation Corps. I also think drug related crime is a huge waste of time, and that the damage caused by drug dealing/smuggling/manufacturing is a fairly direct result of it being illegal, rather than intrinsic to the "industry".
I think the justice system would need to be entirely reformed before it would make sense to reduce prison sentences for violent crime like murder, rape, or kidnapping. Though I think we're doing more harm than good throwing such people in prison for decades without any real rehabilitation involved.
But if you hit someone while driving, you get charged with felony assualt with a deadly weapon.
In the US whenever you see a story about an incredibly long sentence it is almost always because someone did not take into account grouping for sentencing, or they did not take into account that a person is often charges with multiple levels of a crime from the same act, and if convicted on more than one of those charges they are only sentenced on the most severe.
For example in most jurisdictions in if I were to shoot you to death the US there would be multiple degrees of murder that I might be charged with, maybe also multiple degrees of negligent homicide and manslaughter and maybe even others. My sentence if convicted would be the sentence of whichever of those has the longest sentence.
Unfortunately in the US when the Department of Justice issues a press release touting charging someone they don't take those things into account, and so the press release says the person is facing some number of years that can be several times too high.
I'd hold back on believing that he's really facing ~40k years in Turkey until someone familiar with Turkish law and sentencing verifies that things really so work that way in Turkey.
The second thing is that there's no way to measure pain, and also what we feel as pain is more like two things, actual pain, as in nervous system reaction, and suffering, which you create in your mind. There's two-way causation between the two by default, but the effect of one on the other is not deterministic, and can be learnt to that you feel pain, but do not suffer (as much you did previously). So we couldn't measure the pain before, and now we cannot measure the suffering to an even lesser degree.
The third thing is, which usually comes up with regards to crime, is punishment vs rehabilitation. What you describe with the AI, as it stands, is punishment. It's up the person being punished to learn something there. I don't have high expectation of someone who's returned to society after such lengthy torture (or are we killing them afterwards, or keeping them otherwise captive?). In case you're a victim of a crime, or just someone affected, it's natural to thirst punishment for the perpetrator. On a societal level however, it seems like that we're better off with rehabilitation. It creates a better social environment for all.
https://www.uib.no/en/news/100126/norwegian-prisons-rehabili...