and that would make the service better, and eventually cheaper, instead of flying 60 year old designs.
If airplanes are not full, then prices have to go up, not down.
A very possible outcome I see here is that you would probably be given a window in which to checkin, which will no longer hold until 2 hours before the flight, so they can sell the seats that were not claimed a second time
I suspect it doesn't actually work for the simple reason that fuel is the number 1 expense of airlines, and a 50% reduction would be utterly enormous for them - if such a thing existed it would be in extremely high demand.