As long as there is demand for block space, a market will exist. Also, block size can be increased. Bitcoin will need a hard fork anyway to fix the year 2106 problem (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=760).
They've already chosen, no?
>>As long as there is demand for block space, a market will exist.
Of course a market exists. But the current demand will not be enough to secure the network once the subsidy sees a couple halvings.
>>Also, block size can be increased
Both a block size increase and raising the 21 million coin limit are unacceptable according to Bitcoin's current leadership.
Let's work out an actual attack: I send 1000 btc to an exchange, let it confirm, exchange for something else (Ethereum, let's say) and withdraw. Once my ethereum withdraw is seen on that network, I start 51% attacking the bitcoin chain and unwind the dozen or so blocks that have occurred since I sent the deposit. Maybe this attack costs me 500 btc, but in doing so I get my 1000 btc back. So I effectively bought that ethereum at half price by defrauding the exchange. It needs to be a lot of currency because the 500 btc price of the reorg (made up number!) is a fixed cost, independent of the value of the transaction I'm reversing.
The total market cap of bitcoin doesn't enter into this. The most value I can obtain is the lesser of (1) how much bitcoin I have, and (2) what limit the exchange places on deposits. Exchanges (or other trading partners) can put a hold or delay on high-value deposits, which completely mitigates this attack.
Now the expense of the attack is dependent on the mining revenue per block. So if the mining revenue per block is $300k or so, to use a number from the article, then exchanges and other users of bitcoin should require extra confirmations for transactions > $1MM or so.
I don't know about you, but I think it's perfectly acceptable to say that settling a transaction worth $500MM will require waiting for at least a day's worth of confirmations. And that's all that's required to prevent this attack from being profitable at scale.
But the point is the total market cap doesn’t factor into any of those possible attacks, which is what I said was incorrect about Vitalik’s statement.
Are you thinking of Bitcoin Gold?
I sure would. I'm always interested in what people have to say about their competition. When Steve Balmer said iPhones were a losing idea, did I believe him? No, I thought he was making a mistake, to put it politely. But it was instructive to let me know where Microsoft's mindset was at.