"the fact individuals are anti-income tax should tell you all you need to know.."
"the fact criminals are anti-law enforcement should tell you all you need to know.."
Why would a business support unions? Often UNION members dont support other union employees.
Go to a major unionized auto factory sometime and look at the parking lot and try to find "imports".
These same "pro union" individuals also shop at walmart knowing it is not unionized because they like the lower prices.
All of the things you complain about happen on the business side of the table. People are people and do stupid shit with power. Why are Azure VPs buying shit from Amazon? Why do companies park burned out executives for a few years on gardening leave?
Does that work as well, or is this one of those "one way street" deals in your mind?
When have companies "consolidated and exerted unlimited political power"? Did they end up facing "anti-trust" laws? get broken up as a result?
> All of the things you complain about happen on the business side of the table.
Are you sure about that?
here's the head of the UAW being placed on leave for fraud:
https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/uaw-president-leave-corrupt...
Let me guess, the "business" made him do it?
I have no idea what point you are making with Azure?
Why do you care about how the UAW guy defrauded his organization? And why would the company? Amazon fires blue collar workers for peeing too long, why is the stewardship of their dues relevant at all? If anything, they benefit from compromised union leadership.
Not everyone is a FAANG SWE who can get a new gig right away. Some of the proles benefit from protection from the capricious decisions of their employer.
that really is a stretch don't you think?
Perhaps they are buying imports because they know the quality of the product they are building? Perhaps they know the "imports" are better and will last longer?
Does Azure offer socks? what if the Azure VP wanted socks for their kids
You seem to think an Azure VP shopping at Amazon (which only compete on the cloud computing space) is the same as a Unionized autoworker buying a car from a non-union shop????
> Why do you care about how the UAW guy defrauded his organization?
you are the one who said corruption only happens on the "business side of the table".. now you are shown this is incorrect your new position is "why do i care"?
If companies are virtual people can band together and seek collective action, so should actual people. Governance of unions, professional associations, etc are another, irrelevant matter.
Spooky23 2 hours ago | root | parent | next [–]
If you allow companies to consolidate and exert unlimited political power, workers need to be able to self-organize to ensure their interests are represented. Full stop. All of the things you complain about happen on the business side of the table. P "
Clearly you wrote about "business side of the table" when corruption exits on both sides of the table. Often the Unions corruption is rather bad as well (teamsters and organized crime anyone?)
you confuse me, now we are talking about "forest for the trees?"
Statements like this always seem like things people throw out there when they are unable to build a compelling case?
Because in non-right to work states, the workers are forced to contribute part of their paycheck to the UAW. So "the UAW guy defrauded his organization" should really read "the UAW guy defrauded the employees he was supposed to represent."
They did. It was a dirty business.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Alliance
People died.
I took what he wrote, replaced "union" with "company" and asked if this made sense too?
One thing about "fairness" is it should run in both directions.
The point is that there needs to be a better balance of power between both unions (which have literally bankrupt companies) and corporations (which have done really shitty things like "company towns").
Unions may or may not have bankrupted companies, but did they ever engage in the same level of violence, physical intimidation, or criminal behavior as these union busting alliances?
I like unions, but... yes? Pretending that they haven't is ridiculous. There's a reason that people are complaining that police officers can act (nearly) as horrible/brutal as they want to and fact (close to) no consequences. That reason is their union. There's also video of union members physically and mentally attacking people for crossing picket lines, etc.
When people get power, the bad eggs start causing problems for everyone else. And they also tend to gain power, so wind up making decisions for "the organization". This is true of both companies _and_ unions.
The Teamsters in another union that has been mired in controversy due to their behavior.
They got to the point they were simply moving bad teachers around from school to school so our government had to pass laws to rebuild the entire corrupt process.
https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/s02007
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thecurrent/the-current-for-june-7-2...
This nurse murdered a number of patients. her union protected her and hid her misconduct. Instead of being fired, back door deals were made to transfer her from hospital to hospital.
it was easier, firing her would create union problems and so the hospitals agreed to "go with the flow" and allow her to continue killing.
Here (Ontario, Canada) we have dozens and dozens of police collecting full salary for YEARS pending criminal trials.
Cant fire them, cant do anything about it.
Instead of "defund the police" we need a way to reduce the police union power and FIRE bad cops.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Wettlaufer
She killed many people before finally turning herself in. Her union PROTECTED her, hid her mistakes, etc.
Derek Chauvin had like 6 misconduct write-ups.
Elizabeth had over 200
there is no "may or may not".. Unions DID bankrupt several companies.
It is odd you wrote what you did because how many times has the US government ever have to intervene in a corporation due to mob involvement?
"FEDS AGREE TO REDUCE OVERSIGHT OF ONCE-MOB-CORRUPTED TEAMSTERS UNION"
the Department of Justice has a nice site on unions and organized crime
https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ocgs/infiltrated-labor-unio...
As i said, there is a line between "too powerful unions" and "too powerful companies".
You tell us, how much violence did teamsters and their MOB inflict?
where's mr Hoffa?
https://people.howstuffworks.com/10-businesses-supposedly-co...
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/65365/7-businesses-you-p...
https://therealdeal.com/issues_articles/behind-real-estates-...
> Are you sure about that?
> here's the head of the UAW being placed on leave for fraud:
Corporate executives commit fraud and malfeasance all the time on a scale commensurate with their greater power and wealth. They rarely face serious consequences for it. The Wells Fargo fake accounts scandal broke over 5 years ago and hasn't resulted in criminal charges for anyone. Purdue Pharma essentially murdered tens of thousands of people, and the end result for the Sackler family will be that they won't get to keep all of the billions they made off of it. And, of course, the 2008 financial crash. I could go on.
Because i was asked to point out corrupt unions therefor by showing that corrupt corporations exists they "cancel out" one another?
I'd look at US laws to determine why no one was ever prosecuted. In each of the examples you provided it is clearly US crimes and the US justice systems failures?
FWIW, the police are investigating Jerry Dias :
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/unifor-jerry-dias-1.6...
That point is true about unions, too.
I completely get why unions are necessary. But it would be like me hiring a divorce attorney for my own wife.
A business is almost never going to want a union. And it seems weird to expect them to.
I think nearly everyone agrees that unions are going to have a negative impact on profits, that hasn't a point of contention in the debate.
This is also why unions have largely fallen out of fashion except in industries where the workers are well off. Unless you are wealthy enough to burden several months, if not years, without work striking isn't an option and thus the union becomes toothless.
Unions have "fallen out of fashion" in the US because there are not enough labor protections in place. Even now you hear of Starbucks and Amazon even going so far as hiring firms to do hit jobs on union leaders. If you think this is because they are afraid of downtime, rather than having to actually share more of their profits with workers, suit yourself.
The original claim replied to was that profit would decline, not disappear... Talk about a bad take.
> enough labor protections in place.
That's the remainder of the story. Because labour laws have appeared over the decades and centuries, one doesn't have to forego financial stability to save their life like people once had to. Workers now become de facto members of the government union which has already negotiated minimum standards for all. That wasn't always the case.
Those who are in a position to be able to walk away from an income for months at a time may hold on to eek out an ounce more, but it's simply not worth it to low paid workers who rely on a regular paycheque. The cost of losing a home and going hungry greatly outweighs any potential returns.
If you were prioritizing your life then I came and tried to rob you, what would be the chance that you prioritize my angle of attack?
Unions are literally built to prey on that cost that a company IS prioritized and by distracting it with legal hell it becomes slower and risks losing its position in the marketplace and thus potentially vulnerable to negoitations that are unfaorable because of exploiting what would otherwise be prioritization. Your example is just that the vampire sucked too much blood, and has a clear boundary of policy.
For decades they met union demands to avoid costly legal fights.. and in the end?
this is rather old, but telling: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2000/nov/09/2
Instead of restructure, the uion opted for bankruptcy? Way to "protect jobs"?
"The company's attempt to buy more time failed after union leaders rejected a new restructuring plan that would have cut a fifth of the 19,000-strong workforce. The union said its members would have to be paid £70m in wages arrears before it would consider the proposals."
Well, it suggests that unions are effective at creating negative consequences for the company. Those consequences could be "more costly to do business because the employees are paid more"; in theory, a good outcome. They could also be "more costly to do business because it's not against the rules for someone to plug in the monitor in their office because all electronics must be handled by a certified union member" (which actually happens); in theory, a bad outcome.
Not all "bad for the company" things are "good for the employees".
How can a company get honest feedback from their employees without the employees fearing reprisals? A union is one way of doing it since employees (usually) trust their union to take their grievances to the employer with little risk to the employees as individuals or as a group. There was a case a few years ago where a European company opened a factory in the right-to-work state and wanted its workers in a union because that's how it maintained employee relations in their home country. They were confused by the hostility towards unions in that state, both by workers and by the government. IIRC, it was semi-skilled manufacturing so exploiting the workers would be self-defeating if they kept leaving for other jobs.
That's untrue. Especially when workers own part of the company as a part of their compensation.
How does this make sense? Is your ethical framework simply loving everything businesses hate?