Losing the ability to easily swap physical SIM cards seems like a major loss in functionality and robustness for consumers. All for a minor convenience during first setup. Am I missing something?
Losing the ability to easily swap physical SIM cards seems like a major loss in functionality and robustness for consumers. All for a minor convenience during first setup. Am I missing something?
The ability to move SIM cards around isn't something the carrier likes. eSIMs give them that control back.
The ability for you to easily pick up a local SIM while travelling isn't something either the local carrier wants (they'd rather be paid 10x as much in roaming fees) nor your primary carrier wants (they'd rather have you roaming which means they can now tack on a bigger margin on the roaming fees).
eSIM involves the carrier during the provisioning step (the QR code you get is one-time-use) and I don't believe you can move them, which means to move the eSIM the carrier needs to be involved again to give you a new QR code. This could involve fees or other unreasonable requirements.
Sure there's plenty of upsides to eSims
1. You can have any number of eSims on your device and have two active simultaneously, such as one for a data and one for a calling. You can optimise your costs based on who is providing the better deal.
2. You can 'manually' switch out eSims or set up location based shortcuts to put in the correct eSim for you (the automation is useful for people who regularly cross a border.)
3. eSims can be loaded directly from an app, this is how the majority of eSims function - QR codes are just another means of loading an eSim without an app or when using a provider that doesn't support loading eSims without an active data plan.
4. Global eSim data plan providers are competitive. An example is TruPhone which I found cheaper than local alternatives. Local providers cash in on holidaymakers.
5. Purchasing a local calling plan requires ID such as a passport (regardless for eSim or physical sim cards), if just needing data however: global eSim-based data providers don't have this burden.
6. Switching physical sims can wear them down to become faulty (such as by touching their contacts them too much) - eSim can be sent digitally or scanned from a physical card. It's much faster to get a phone back on a network with eSims than it is physical sims.
The -real- downsides of eSims:
1. eSims are largely the domain of wealthier countries. Many African providers don't have local eSim offerings (but the global providers still function of course).
2. China is a notable hold out on eSims because data plans can be obtained without providing your ID to the government, there is a similar story with other countries that have tight filtering/control over their internet.
My quick web search revealed eSIMs to be non-portable.
Clearly Apple is going to save billions of dollars because they don't have to include those little metal sim tray openers in the box anymore.
Jokes aside, I doubt people swap sims very often and when they do it is because they are doing a first setup. International travel is obviously an instance where people do swap sims but I expect it will become easier to use esim for this now that you have to.
I welcome the move to esim-only and have been using it since the Pixel 2. Having to stick a little 256KB card into the side of my state of the art, thousand dollar phone just so it can connect to a cellular network and having to get a new card if I want to swap networks is ridiculous.
I think it is a huge inconvenience. When I was with my stepdad, trying to port a SIM to an eSIM took over 20 minutes. Since my mom wasn't there, we attempted to call her because they needed at least the last four of her SSN and the account password (which she couldn't remember).
In the end, we found out that we could simply just pop out the old SIM and put it in the new phone. That took us all of 30 seconds.
Probably also comes with a minor reduction in material / manufacturing costs? One less port and moving part that has to be waterproofed.