We've had -Werror forever, the consensus is it's a bad idea. In addition to everything else, you can't ever change the warnings, including fixing bugs in them, without potentially breaking code.
> We've had -Werror forever, the consensus is it's a bad idea.
Says who? Package repo maintainers? -Werror is actually quite divisive.
Anyone who wants to be able to compile a program with a different or newer compiler than the author last tested it on.