I get the impression that the problem was less about scaling within one database than about scaling across many; Lenton practically says as much about a half dozen messages down-thread. Deploying literally millions of separate databases would be a total nightmare of resource contention, version skew, and general administrative burden. U1 was probably looking for ways to use some sort of multi-tenancy to serve the same number of users with fewer CouchDB instances, and that's the kind of scalability they apparently found lacking. Your point about scale vs. federation, while perhaps accurate and valuable, doesn't seem to address the actual reason for this change.