I mean in the sense that it feels like you're suggesting that "offsetting expenses" makes it better. When it makes it worse. [1]. So in answering the question "is this taxable income" - the answer is "yes". If you wanted to qualify it more it would be more along the lines of "not just tax, there's likely a lot of other expenses incurred as well."
[1] Yes, it's better in the pure sense that there's "less tax", but overall there's more expenses than the tax that was saved.
I guess the reply seemed strange to me because it started the thought, and then kinda didn't complete it.
The post could have just said "yes", or could have mentioned the additional costs and explained that taxes were not the only likely overhead. But (it read to me) like the thought was incomplete, or was somehow implying the expenses were a good thing.
Clearly though I misunderstood it - my bad.