Pushing Back on the Expanding Universe Theory
jarbles.substack.com
jarbles.substack.com
This sentence shows you don't understand the history of how we got here. When Einstein published the theory of relativity he added a constant term to an equation to enable the theory to describe a static state universe. This goes totally counter to your "conspiracy theory". In fact he missed a shot at predicting the big bang theory!
Clearly Einstein missed his opportunity to lead the way in devising a theory of quantum mechanics, he was using his intuition and his method of thought experiment, and did not progress our understanding there. But when it comes to larger, more stable phenomena, I'm not so sure his intuition was so far off
Yes. That part. Hinduism doesn't have it. And again: Einstein explicitly added a constant term to an equation to make it so that his theory did NOT imply a beginning. He wasn't Hindu mind you. He was Jewish!
> You are entitled to believe what you like, but use the word "incorrect" when you know something is false
That seems a bit much honestly. It's like Christians saying "you don't KNOW there is no God!!!". But yea.. I do. I also know the fact about Einstein above.
Just because SOME people want to show there is a start of time, doesn't mean it's the prevailing scientific theory for that reason. In fact, again like I said above, we know this isn't so as a historical fact.
So much physics misunderstanding right there.
The red hue of the sky is from filtering by dispersion. The spectroscopy of red sunlight during sunset is similar to the spectroscopy of regular sunlight. You have same absorption lines. Just lower amplitudes in higher frequencies.
Redshift from stars moves the absorption lines. There are no known mediums which would have this effect after light left the medium. The only things which have that effect are gravitation and Doppler shift. Those are literally the two things astrophysicists take into account very well, leading to current theories.
Or you're suggesting a violation of conservation of energy and momentum of light over large distances, by vacuum itself. Which would probably be detectable here. Not even sure how you can suggest it in a consistent way.
Then there's the reasonable option, that it's just gravity and the spacetime metric itself changing, which is the leading theory anyways. Explaining it away with some invisible matter that acts only gravitationally, like you suggested, is literally what they are doing.
And what about particles we do see? What if the debris we know is out there (the stuff of collisions and non-congealed leftover particulates, early gases since its many light years away) over immense distances have an accumulative affect? We see the red sunset but do not discern any individual particles with our eyes.
Then there are the things we don't see. Dark matter... and so much of it. I'm guessing that disproving the relevance of all of this has proven tedious, and recounting it to a newbie like myself even more tiresome!
I am obviously a complete layman when it comes to physics (I started studying physics at uni but switched comp science after a time, I simply not quick enough at learning math) but I have always seen the expanding universe as suggested as the explanation solely since it uses a known mechanism (the Doopler effect). It feels to me like the other explanations given in this article lacks most of an mechanism even. Though I have not read up on the evidence Sean Carroll has given, as referenced by the article.
That said if JWST is providing us with evidence counter to what would be expected from an expanding universe then I will of course (as I hope the rest of the expanding universe cabal will) change our mind and go for more fitting models.
Tired light also doesn't explain the observed stretching in time of supernova light curves with distance.
Ned Wright explains this at his web site:
Frequency is precisely the necessary thing that needs to be considered as an observed phenomenon that can have alternative explanations, since frequency relates to shifting toward red.
Are you saying that density/luminosity is an independent way of corroborating universal expansion? I don't believe that's the case.
Neither luminosity nor redshift seem, IMHO, to be strong enough evidence to uphold a "preposterous" (to use Sean Carroll's favorite descriptive term for the world) theory that massive things are not just traveling but accelerating away from oneanother.
It also falsely predicts that SN light curves are not stretched out at higher red shift.
Theories that make incorrect predictions are dead theories. We know for sure they are wrong.
This has nothing to do with the Big Bang, btw. Science works by killing theories, and tired light has been slain. It would be ruled out even if there wasn't an alternative theory available.
What you are proposing is ruled out by the generic argument against all such tired light theories.
I'm getting very strong crank vibes from you now.
Another apparent violation of the speed limit occurs beyond the event horizon of a black hole. Space itself is drawn to the singularity faster than light.
Separating "space itself" from the objects that are governed by universal laws is like saying there could be a north pole without a planet such as Earth. Take away Earth, you have no north pole. Take away objects in motion, you have no basis for talking about spacetime. That's just my intuition, but it seems to point to a gap in explanations, at least from science popularizers.
(It’s not like the subject experts don’t realize the dangers of one or two observations or approaches holding up a theory, especially in a field like astronomy where you’re stuck with the experiments nature deigned to perform for you. That’s why the Bullet Cluster is not the knock-out argument for dark matter that it appears to be—it’s a single object, maybe it’s some kind of freak occurrence we can’t really sort out from here.)
Generally speaking, Weinberg’s Cosmology (not to be confused with his GR textbook Gravitation and cosmology from the 70s, the cosmology parts of which are much too old to be useful) is a bit peculiar in a way that might be helpful here: Weinberg is undeniably one of the giants of modern physics, but not in cosmology, astronomy, gravitation, or similar—he’s a high-energy person first and foremost, with connections to other field-theoretic pursuits. So AFAIU writing a cosmology textbook was just his way of learning how the subject developed over the three decades when he wasn’t looking (spoiler alert: a lot).
Thus he tends to pay attention to which pieces of reasoning and evidence hold up the subject to an extent that people immersed in it don’t—including things that a normal astronomer considers elementary knowledge not really part of cosmology proper, like Hertzsprung—Russell (and, to be fair to the astronomer, it really isn’t).
That doesn’t mean that he’ll hold your hand: if you don’t know special relativity, the book’s probably going to be mostly unreadable (Taylor—Wheeler and a bit of Lightman—Press—Price—Teukolsky be with you); if you don’t know enough Riemann geometry to write down a geodesic equation, ditto (try Misner—Thorne—Wheeler maybe? it really is a cursed subject); same for not being able to derive said equation from an action, or not knowing how blackbody radiation works. All of those are proven as well as anything can be, though, and hold up much more than just cosmology.
This theory also provides a physical mechanism for time dilation and increase of momentum at relativistic velocities by modifying general relativity. I would be curious what you think of it:
Does anyone know where this list of 4 or 5 evidences that the universe is expanding are that Sean Carroll outlines? I had the link but am not finding it!!
I don’t know, but it seems to me that those words have no place in science or any discussion of it.
Stopped reading there, not because I think the "election was stolen" but because I have no idea what petty US politics have to do in an article about astrophysics
If you inflate the balloon, our universe expands. Points get farther away from each other, proportionally to how far away they started. In this analogy, we're not expanding into anything we can see or feel or know anything about, the only real difference is that points are a bit farther apart.
Because it's space expanding, not something moving inside of space. It doesn't follow the same rules.
If space is what fills an area between object A and object B and that space grows or expands. This is no different than object A moving away from object B. What's the difference? There seems to be none.
My question to people who actually know this subject: has 'c' been proven to be constant, resisting expansion? The speed of light/causality might be affected if time also expanded along with space? Or how can space expand without time expanding given its relationship with time?
Astrophysics, like quantum physics, isn't intuitive in the same way that classical, human-scale physics is to us.
But what if it isn't, and everything except for space is actually shrinking, galaxies, nebula, stars, planets, are actually getting smaller at a fantastic rate?
I'm not serious.
This is where the lack of expertise in physics really shines through, and exemplifies my problems with this article. In science, a lot of knowledge and intuition gets built up but not published because it's "too obvious", and doesn't get communicated to laypeople because it's a mix of too advanced and too unimportant.
It's much more believable to me that physicists implicitly understand why there would be many more issues with alternatives theories to the expansion of the universe. And physicists rarely claim to have a perfect model anyway, opting for "best model that currently fits the evidence".
Maybe more evidence will come out against the expanding universe theory (the new JWST results could be the beginning) and will lead to a paradigm shift. And I appreciate highlighting the big assumption of "redshift is from Doppler". But the bulk of this article has low credibility to me.
You are saying I'm a lay person? You nailed it. I'm quite curious though about what would be so "advanced" that pop-science writers would not want to at least allude to it, since just Doppler redshift observations seems like not such a sturdy foundation, especially without anything else buttressing it!