Self-referencing 'We the People' petition has only one day left | Hacker News Reader

Self-referencing 'We the People' petition has only one day left

wwws.whitehouse.gov

33 pointseof4 comments

Why should I consider it desirable that the white house listen to those who like to talk the most, rather than assuming that my views are represented by my representatives elected in an organized process?

Overly participatory democracy leads to government of the busy bodies, the people with too much time on their hands and too enthusiastic about government power to solve problems.

For every worthwhile public uproar like SOPA, there hundreds of little groups out there trying to get the government to listen to incredibly stupid demands.

The US style of winner-take-all representative democracy creates a huge collective action problem. My ballot choices boil down to "mediocre to useless", "complete wingnut", and a few somewhat preferable third party candidates I don't dare vote for because dividing the mediocre vote guarantees the wingnut wins. A third party can't succeed unless they somehow manage to attract today's left and right wing voters in equal and large numbers. In the meantime, my views are being safely ignored—they just never seem to be on the radar of my only feasible choice from the ballot.

I would much prefer direct democracy within a sharply limited scope of government powers. A laboratory of the states, with a couple dozen hellholes and a few places I'd be eager to live. But I don't see a path from here to there.

For every worthwhile public uproar like SOPA, there hundreds of little groups out there trying to get the government to listen to incredibly stupid demands.

From the RIAA and MPAA's points of view, it is a very necessary bill, and every little group thinks their bill is very urgent. So, there are thousand of opposition groups who think the proposer's bill as being very bad or unnecessary.

Then you got politicians elected by the constituent to do what they wanted to do, and damn everyone else. It's the reason why congress sucks, but our representative rocks.

We hate all politicians but I voted for that politician because he brought us jobs.

Isn't that the reason why our government continue to do nothing and everything in the worst possible way?

Indeed, it seems strange that the legislative branch make laws that take away our freedom and judges, despite being appointed by congress, protect our freedom.

Between refreshes, the number of signatures needed jumped from 3 to 16. I wonder what happened.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com