Sure, there are other challenges, but it’s too simple to say that anything else but nuclear is worth it.
Sure, there are other challenges, but it’s too simple to say that anything else but nuclear is worth it.
> but it’s too simple to say that anything else but nuclear is worth it.
Nonsense. You call my argument "simplistic", but all you've done is point out how great you think electric engines are, as if that says anything at all about nuclear energy or the philosophy behind its opponents.
Everything has risk. Solar panels can fall and kill you. Wind turbines kill birds.
> And nuclear does pollute a lot more.
Oh really. Tell me more.
> If we plaster the world with nuclear reactors, risk and pollution goes up.
What pollution? What about CO2?
> You dismiss these two factors as completely irrelevant.
That's because it is irrelevant.
What you were doing is applying a benefit of a technology to a situation where it's anything but impressive. In the most logically extreme circumstance, imagine if humanity achieved unlimited power; why would anyone care at that point whether their electric engine was even 200% more efficient than an internal combustion engine? Without something to make the efficiency meaningful, such as energy shortage or personal cost, it wouldn't matter. What you appear to be saying is that electric engines running on wind and solar can replace nuclear as if they can as easily scale and be as affordable, neither of which are true because they can't produce electrical energy 24/7/365 the way nuclear energy can.
You're not saving "50% energy" if you're not generating that energy efficiently in the first place. And nuclear is best way to have consistent stream of it without massive storage facilities that renewables would require