Don’t get me wrong, I think Citzens United is a horrible ruling, and this whole fiasco just further shows the “rules for thee but not for me” doctrine the Republican Party has been operating for the past 25 odd years.
Don’t get me wrong, I think Citzens United is a horrible ruling, and this whole fiasco just further shows the “rules for thee but not for me” doctrine the Republican Party has been operating for the past 25 odd years.
Ok, it's been privatized, but can the government abdicate it's responsibility to protect freedom of speech by privatizing?
Edit because I'm "posting too fast": Paying for most of the infrastructure didn't make TV stations or phone companies exempt from similar regulation. I don't see why it would make social networks exempt.
If the government of Texas wants a free for all social platform, they can create one.
Actually, it seems like they can create these laws, that have been upheld by the court system as being completely legal.
And then if social media companies break these completely legal laws, then they will be massively fined and ordered by the court to change.
What if friends who have a variety of opinions just want to be able to communicate with each other?
Or what if someone wants to hear all the facts without censorship? Maybe the Hunter Biden's laptop story was true, but you wouldn't hear that on Twitter. Maybe Trump was very wrong about Invermectin, but you wouldn't hear that on Truth Social.
What if someone believes that open debate is better for democracy than a few alternative echo chambers?
So they are actually going to be able to engage on facebook and twitter, pretty soon.
Can I come to your private residence with a group of friends and spout any type of none sense? Isn’t it telling that conservatives can’t come up with a successful social media platform?
I don't have 50 million users, so no the law would not apply to my private residence.
The law instead applies to large social media companies. And the law is allowed by the court system.
If I get 50 million users at some point, running a multi-billion dollar company, then yes the law would apply to me.
> until it is overturned.
I'd recommend that you read up on the supreme court opinions on this. They have already made some statements, that is looking like they are not going to overturn the law.
We have all sorts of laws that only apply to large companies yes.
For example, a random example would be anti-trust laws. Literally they only start applying if you have a large enough effect on the market.
It is an established precedent in many parts of the law.
And similarly, common carrier laws haven't been that controversial. Parties from all sides of the political spectrum support our existing common carrier laws.
Landline phones and the internet infrastructure and the cell network are all examples of natural monopolies, a website is not a natural monopoly.
Instead, I gave an example of how it is an established precedent that yes certain laws only apply if a company is large, or has a large market effect.
Are you actually unaware that there are laws that only apply if a company is large enough?
There are laws that only apply if a company has enough employees, and tax stuff that applies only above certain revenue, but I'm not actually aware of any other regulations that apply if a company has too many customers.
It takes into account market power.
> and a monopoly isn't inherently in violation of anti-trust laws.
Good thing that I didn't say that every single monopoly, ever, is in violation of anti-trust law then.
> A small company can engage in anti-competitive practices
It can, yes. But the law is much more likely to make these practices illegal if the company has a large amount of market power.
So yes, the more market power, or larger influence, that a company has, the more likely that some, but not all, laws will apply to them and regulate their behavior.
So they don't "only" apply if the company is large enough? That's what I thought.
Some laws DO "only" apply if a company has a large enough market power, yes.
The point of the statement, is the general concept of a company being "large", having an effect on if the law applies or not.
> That's what I thought.
Actually, my previous statement is correct, you just mis-interpreted it. Because I was referring to this general concept of a company being large, and how some laws include this factor as a metric that is relevant to if the law applies.
So I was correct the entire time, you just made up a different idea to attack because you were not able to understand what I was saying.
Instead, we live in a democracy, and if these social media companies don't like it then they can move to a different country.
These laws are legal, according to the court system.
You are the one who is going to have to find a different country if you don't like them.
The big companies lost. Deal with it.
If Texas was just blocked from posting to Twitter, nothing of value would be lost.
There is no such limitation in someone setting up servers and connecting it to the internet and creating an alternate social media platform. Are there not enough conservatives with the finances and knowledge to create a Twitter alternative? I’ll gladly over charge them and lead the effort if they pay enough. Leading infrastructure and back end development is kind of my thing.
And once again, it's not about having alternative walled gardens (which already exist). It's about promoting open debate on all platforms. What's wrong with that? If censorship is the only way your ideas can win, your ideas suck.
Incidentally, this also protects the far left if Elon Musk ends up buying Twitter.
Again, conservatives love “limited government” and the free markets until neither work in their favor.
Truth Social is an existence proof that the free market is working as it should.