https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
So, for background, I am now a teacher. This year, I'm teaching:
* Middle School: Competitive math (MathCounts), Competitive robotics (FTC), Intro to Circuits (undergraduate EE curriculum slightly simplified and slowed down), Mechatronics Lab (3D design, embedded software, and controls).
* High School: AP Microeconomics (College level economics course), Competitive robotics (FTC), Spacecraft Systems Engineering (hoping to get a launch grant to put a small satellite in orbit).
* Clubs: HS Investment club, HS Space club, upper elementary math and robotics clubs.
I'm all about things being student led and student owned; this is especially true in my team classes (robotics and math). Even the others, I try to attain this to the extent possible.
On the other hand... Look, we've got a few hundred bodies around. We need a bell and to know where students should be. And my students do need to learn to work on things that are not necessarily their first choice of what to do, because for a lot of students this would be Fortnite 24/7. And for a lot of subject, there are pieces of information that are useless on their own until you've built a whole conceptual loop around them.
The piece makes an argument for market forces. Unfortunately, market forces often push things in the "wrong" direction. Parents want their kids to take lots of AP classes because it is helpful to get into college and also saves college tuition. But I feel like the microeconomics course I'm teaching is a lot worse than the one I'd teach on my own... I dare not stray too much from the dictates of the College Board, though, because students need to pass that test. Parents also like "rigor" of students working meekly and quietly because it seems like it's a quality signal (and it often is, but too much of anything is crap!).
What we really need is:
* Rigorous, controlled educational research so that we can know what works and what doesn't in what populations. Spoiler: everyone is just making it all up as they go along or, at best, following new educational trends with very little research support for them
* An educational system that actually respects and implements that research.
* Respect, safety, and adequate resources for teachers. (I do extraordinary things with my classes in large part I teach in a very easy environment-- from class sizes, organizational support, resourcing, and student behavior).
is a two way street. Teachers routinely blame the parents for any failures in the classroom.
> safety
absolutely.
> adequate resources
I never learned more than at Caltech where the material was taught with blackboard and chalk, and the students used pen and paper.
What also made it fun was the interaction with the audience and I'd just go where those interactions led.
I don't do this normally, because everyone expects slides, and the conference organizer provides no mechanism for blackboards.
Also, blackboards are problematic for a larger venue, they work best in a normal sized classroom.
It should be a little unpredictable what class will be like each day.
> is a two way street. Teachers routinely blame the parents for any failures in the classroom.
I teach in a great environment, but my public school peers are frequently berated by parents of students that complete no work.
Even in my environment, I am pretty constantly "talked down to" by parents-- there's the implicit assumption they're better than me. I have enough confidence from past successes in industry and life to shrug it off, but I could easily see it becoming demotivating. Someone with my skills can easily find more lucrative and less challenging work.
> > adequate resources
> I never learned more than at Caltech where the material was taught with blackboard and chalk, and the students used pen and paper.
I teach computer engineering with pen and paper.
I mean things like "a living wage", "time to prepare for your classes and go to the bathroom", "not sticking 40 middle school students, including many with severe behavioral problems, in one room", and "not having to buy pencils and other necessities for your students with your own money".
There's also a whole lot of nice-to-haves that make a difference. The $15 set of refillable whiteboard pens that have a very wide nib and make huge dark lines are very useful, but ain't no public school teacher going to get those over worn-out Expo markers. Candy bribes and stickers used judiciously as prizes to fuel classroom competition make a difference. Etc, etc, etc.
Sure, there are rotten parents. No excuse for them. But I'm talking about a general disrespect teachers have for parents. This is manifested in not wanting any input from parents, not wanting to hear from them at PTA meetings, not consulting parents in any way shape or form about the curriculum. Teachers do want parents to volunteer, but only at their direction. No collaboration.
As for pencils and paper, pencils cost a few cents each, and the playgrounds of the schools I attended were littered with pencils. Paper is so cheap people throw away reams of unused paper all the time.
Me, I prefer the more expensive $5 gel pens, but they'll last me a couple months each.
P.S. My dad taught at university for years. He grew up in the Depression, and his thrifty ways followed for the rest of his life. He'd bring home used paper - such as exams printed on one side of the sheet, and blank the other side. His notes and drafts and accounts and tax records were done on the blank side. I have many boxes filled with those papers. When they were inadequate, he'd buy boxes of newsprint, the cheapest paper possible, and write from edge to edge in tiny script. Nobody could get more out of a piece of paper than my dad :-)
It's easy to blame teachers for this, but in public schools generally greater than 100% of instructional time is already spoken for. Administrators and regulators are heaping requirements upon teachers to cover material. Then, because not enough time is allotted, the only option is to cover it badly and quickly.
Also, because many teachers have inadequate planning and grading time, it gets really tempting to do what you did last year; veteran teachers tend to work >125% of contract hours already.
I'm open to collaboration. Unlike most teachers, I have a lot of flexibility in how I run most of my classes. But AP Microeconomics? Pfft. I don't have the luxury of caring what your suggestions are about how I run that class. I have 34.5 equivalent-block-periods of material to cover in 35.5 equivalent-block-periods, and I'm sure there will be a fire drill or something that I need to reteach that will claim that buffer.
This is just a snippet of the high level plan (lesson plans go into greater detail), showing how I'm forced to think about a class where there's explicit heavy curriculum requirements: https://i.imgur.com/YQk5LBP.png
> As for pencils and paper, pencils cost a few cents each, and the playgrounds of the schools I attended were littered with pencils.
That's nice. You are still trying to shame someone who is making below a living wage to purchase it, and many other things, for other peoples' children.
You can't expect respect for that. (BTW, other teachers have told me their reason for not caring about parental input is they were trained professionals and parents were ignorant fools.)
> You are still trying to shame someone who is making below a living wage to purchase it
$4 to supply all your students with pencils. You brought up the pencil thing. Besides, you should move to Seattle where public schoolteachers make 6 figure salaries, have a pension for life, gold plated health insurance, and 2 months off per year.
> You can't expect respect for that.
Rock vs. hard place? If I go off track in one of these classes where curriculum is tightly specified, quantitative indicators nosedive and I get crucified by parents.
> Besides, you should move to Seattle where public schoolteachers make 6 figure salaries, have a pension for life, gold plated health insurance, and 2 months off per year.
I make ~$59k/year for a 104% teaching load in the San Francisco Bay Area.
Teaching my circuits class, I've bought a few hundred dollars in soldering irons and integrated circuits and breadboards for my classroom. The school borrows my old digital storage oscilloscope and other tools. I also end up pitying the robotics teams and buying them lots of stuff.
I got rich in industry so this works OK for me, but...
And yes, if I went and got a master's degree, I could make a bit more in public education, in exchange for a much worse classroom environment and lower level of respect. Still would be nowhere near the pay I could get elsewhere.
I see that pencil trope all the time. In Seattle, they run a school supplies drive every year and pencils figure prominently on the donation list. This is a school system that spends $16,941 per student, and yet begs for $.05 pencils.
"San Francisco Unified School District spends $17,464 per student each year" sez google. I infer your complaint is misdirected at the taxpayers, and should be with mis-spending by the school administrators.
Read actual teacher accounts of what they spend kitting out their classrooms.
And yes, public school systems spend massive amounts per student, and then still expect charity from everyone: employees, parents, the community, etc, to fund normal operations and provide normal supplies.
Your digs at mandated curriculum, how cheap the supplies are, etc... are really beside the point. They're like yelling at the front-line customer service rep who has no power to affect the things that concern you.
Public school systems are often kafkaesque. Classrooms with 40 students; administration that externalize all problems to the teachers and refuse to address behavior problems; IEPs for 20 of those students mandating "preferential seating" and individualized teaching interventions. Curriculum that is garbage and overspends classroom time. Asking teachers to develop massive amounts of materials themselves. Or alternatively to only use provided material with no enrichment. Sometimes alternating between opposing harsh policy lines every few months.
Yes, there's some moderately high comp'd teaching jobs out there (lol not mine) and some situations which fare better on respect and autonomy (like mine). But if it were such a sweet gig, we'd not have teachers leaving the field in droves and a shortage.
[And the intrinsics of the job itself are wonderful-- teaching successfully feels great. You really have to try hard to screw it up to make teachers miserable, and that's what our society does].
> Asking teachers to develop massive amounts of materials themselves.
Another thing I cannot comprehend. How many 5th grade teachers are there in the US? 10,000? How many lesson plans have to be developed? 10,000? This is absurd. Any other industry would share lesson plans. Teachers also tell me that each summer for their grade, they have to develop the 5th grade lesson plans all over again. I asked why not reuse last year's? One teacher told me she had to customize them for each student. I asked her how she could customize them over the summer when students weren't assigned to classes until school started. She didn't reply.
> You really have to try hard to screw it up to make teachers miserable, and that's what our society does
More like that's what socialism does. The public schools are a service provided by the government, and exhibits all aspects of socialism. Your observation that the public schools are Kafkaesque is right on target. More money will not fix them.
Something doesn't add up.
The school is perfectly capable of getting pencils. The local public school teachers get $150/year for supplies and classroom decorations for ~30 kids. And they get yelled at if their room ends up looking spartan.
> Any other industry would share lesson plans.
Yup! We have things like teachers-pay-teachers where you can make a few bucks sharing lesson plans. We have some districts that give teachers a small amount of funds to use this.
We have other districts forbid teachers using any resources not provided by the district or the teacher themselves. Often "quality concerns" are really code for "we want someone local to blame if there's something in the material we don't like".
> Teachers also tell me that each summer for their grade, they have to develop the 5th grade lesson plans all over again.
The main reason you need to do this is if there's a major schedule change or upstream curriculum requirement change. Though, it's reasonable to plan to throw away 20-25% each year for other reasons.
For my classes, there's a lot of drift. I don't need to teach as much basic material in the robotics programs because I have veteran students and a lot of the knowledge spreads by osmosis. In turn, I need to e.g. figure out how to tell a bunch of 7th and 8th graders who haven't had linear algebra yet about state estimation filters this year.
Also, ... cookie cutter using common curriculum isn't great. My school purchased me the "best" set of economics slides. There's a lot of stuff I can get across clearly in a fraction of the time. There's other stuff that I feel I need to hammer harder, and have to cobble together other materials and my own creations to fill that in. I'm adjusting things for the specific class that I have (e.g. a very math-strong econ class this year), and I'm adjusting things for my specific strengths and weaknesses in lecturing to the class.
Finally, if you just try to duplicate last year's class, it's probable that you won't have the energy of presentation and excitement and effectiveness. You need to have new lessons to look forward to and some degree of discomfort / newness that you're experiencing with the class to be the best possible educator, I think.
> More like that's what socialism does. The public schools are a service provided by the government, and exhibits all aspects of socialism. Your observation that the public schools are Kafkaesque is right on target. More money will not fix them.
Again, you're not arguing with what I'm saying. I've already acknowledged we spend lots of money on schools for the most part. On the other hand, teachers from other countries with public education mostly shake their heads at what public school teachers in the US need to deal with.
The grass is always greener effect, and who knows what really is happening in foreign schools without being there. They may be just telling Americans what they want to be true. A more interesting comparison is with local charter schools.
> We have other districts forbid teachers using any resources not provided by the district or the teacher themselves.
Haha, just use them anyway. It's not like they're going to check. Besides, the teacher can reuse what he used last year, or copy one from a fellow teacher. There ought to be quite a surfeit of materials from other 5th grade teachers in the same district. There ought to be lesson plans coming out of their ears if each teacher was redoing them every year.
Most teachers I had just followed the Teacher's Edition of the textbook. I didn't see any evidence of lesson plans.
Perhaps in high school things change from year to year, but they can't be changing that much, and why would 5th grade math change?
Personally, I rarely reuse lectures I give. This is because the technology changes constantly, my old lectures are available online, and when I get invited to speak and the conference is paying the bill I think it's disrespectful to use old material. Also I just get bored with what I did before :-)
I never directed a complaint at the taxpayers-- though it should be directed at the voters. Society expecting/normalizing teachers to pay for supplies out of their own pocket is the problem.
Education keeps getting more and more expensive and lower and lower quality across the board. Especially in universities, but also in K12. Administration and waste gobble up more and more.
It seems like your responses expect teachers to paper over all the systemic problems. Their employer demands they teach excessive amounts of curriculum? Well, they'd better listen to parents, too, even if this is impossible, or else get no respect! School districts don't actually buy supplies or resource classrooms sufficiently? Well, teachers had better fix that!
The solution is, and you know this is coming (!), free market schools.
A half-step in that direction are charter schools, which the teachers unions fight tooth and nail.
I've never talked with a public school teacher who had anything positive to say about charter schools.
If teachers are shamed into buying supplies for their room, it's not propaganda.
> A half-step in that direction are charter schools, which the teachers unions fight tooth and nail.
Charter schools are pretty complicated from a policy perspective. We're not talking about the same thing in different states. Some of the for-profit charter schools are much worse than public schools. Other areas have sane regulatory regimes that result in an OK product.
Even there, though, students in charter schools do not do better than students who applied for the school but didn't win "lotteries" to get in. That is, the performance benefit seems to mostly be tied to selection effects relating to parental involvement.
> I've never talked with a public school teacher who had anything positive to say about charter schools.
Welp, I'm not a public school teacher, but there is a decent charter school in town.
If you don't want to give up on special education, this is difficult to do.
I favor policies like vouchers for ~33% of public educational cost to be used at private institutions. This is enough to make private education more affordable to many more families (especially with institution financial aid), but could possibly increase resources-per-student for the remaining students in public schools.
If you want to do this at a public school, you're going to need to go get a specialized master's degree and teaching credential. Of course, there's some value in what's taught in these programs (pedagogy, classroom management, practical experience, etc). I've studied rather intensely on my own.
Feynman, perhaps the greatest physics teacher ever, had 0 teaching credentials. I attended one of his lectures long ago, a privilege I didn't realize until much later.
I highly respect you, and we seem to talk here a lot. But you have this habit of holding up various edge cases that don't quite directly relate to what we're talking about as "gotchas".
I have 0 teaching credentials, too, and think I'm pretty great. The current systems we have for younger students require teaching credentials, and there's some good reasons to require some education-in-education before letting someone teach kids.
::: It's easier to pick a good teacher than to train one: Familiar and new results on the correlates of teacher effectiveness
Neither holding a college major in education nor acquiring a master's degree is correlated with elementary and middle school teaching effectiveness, regardless of the university at which the degree was earned. Teachers generally do become more effective with a few years of teaching experience, but we also find evidence that teachers may become less effective with experience, particularly later in their careers. These and other findings with respect to the correlates of teacher effectiveness are obtained from estimations using value-added models that control for student characteristics as well as school and (where appropriate teacher) fixed effects in order to measure teacher effectiveness in reading and math for Florida students in fourth through eighth grades for eight school years, 2001–2002 through 2008–2009.
Research highlights ▶ Majoring in education is not associated with teacher effectiveness. ▶ University attended for college is not associated with teacher effectiveness. ▶ Acquiring a master's degree is not associated with teacher effectiveness. ▶ Teachers become more effective with a few years of teaching experience. ▶ Teachers may become less effective later in their careers.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S02727...
It doesn't mean taking more people without teaching credentials results in an equal or greater quality of education.
e.g. I am a high school dropout who's doing pretty-damn-well at teaching. I do not think this means we need more high school dropouts teaching, though.
I've learned a whole lot reading the pedagogy literature and reading about the kinds of strategies that credentialed teachers are required to learn during their practicum and student teaching. It's difficult to imagine that these courses of study are not useful.
(The research does probably mean that programs intended to incentivize existing teachers to get graduate degrees are probably flawed, except for some special cases in e.g. secondary math education)
I agree that specialized techniques help with specific learning disabilities, I've seen it in action. But for ordinary kids (the vast majority), the teacher just walks through the textbook for the class. The smarter kids just read the textbook and learn it themselves, as the teacher is moving too ssllooooooowwllyy.
Frankly, the teachers didn't know what to do with me. Some wanted to be rid of me. Some liked me. I don't recall learning much from any of them.
My history teacher would show Mr Magoo movies. I'm not kidding. My auto shop teacher would show drag racing newsreels. I did like my wood shop teacher. He taught me how to use machine tools and not cut my fingers off (he'd lost his in a table saw). That's paid off dividends for me my whole life since. But I don't think that required special teaching training. I learned how to use metal working machine tools in college from the head machinist, who simply enjoyed showing me how to run them.
IMO: This is a terrible way to teach. Even for very highly curriculum-driven classes like the microeconomics class I'm teaching.
My block periods are 1 hour 16 minutes. This is a long, long time to be giving dry lecture or popcorn-reading a textbook.
Bell-ringer activities and exit tickets. Gimkit to break up long lectures and get an instant reading of mastery. Appropriate strategies towards looping and unit construction. Pacing, formative vs. summative assessments.
Just how to effectively create discussions is tricky. Everyone looked a bit zoned out when we're talking about consumer surplus. "EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU HAS EXPERIENCED CONSUMER SURPLUS." Huh? "EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU HAS EXPERIENCED CONSUMER SURPLUS. Tell me when!" a few seconds of silence... eventually "Uhm.. there was a thing of candy and it had 4 pieces, and said 25 cents on it. I thought it was 25 cents apiece and I brought a dollar to the counter, but I got 75 cents back..." "Boom! That's 75 cents of consumer surplus!" Cue everyone sharing their concept of it and internalizing it when I had been losing the whole class.
I didn't have training. But I did have a year where I didn't have many classes to teach and I had a very masterful teacher on the other side of the wall and I could listen to him and learn some of what he did. And I've read a whole lot about pedagogy and research from the National Training Laboratories about what are best practices.
> My history teacher would show Mr Magoo movies.
lol. I'm about to show a 2 minute clip from a cartoon where a shopkeeper says that it's Christmas Eve and that they're going to "jack the prices to the moon" because the customer has no other choice to illustrate elasticity of supply and demand.
> He taught me how to use machine tools and not cut my fingers off
I teach robotics, and that means teaching the use of machine tools to middle school and high school students that have no common sense. It is stressful. I agree no one trains you for that :D
Clearly, some teachers are better at it than others. But if anyone did a study and found that Masters in Ed teachers did a better job than Bachelors in Ed teachers, I'd be genuinely surprised.
I've spent my whole career "teaching" in that sense. Explaining things, mentoring junior engineers, etc.
There's definitely skill transfer from that, but it's a bit different of a thing to try and take 25 12-year olds of vastly different backgrounds and ability for a year and get most of them to master a given curriculum.
I missed the first 3 months of 4th grade. The teacher told my mom that they had advanced very quickly, and I could never catch up. I would have to be put back in 3rd grade. My mom said nope, Walter is going in 4th grade.
It was as if I wasn't gone a day. 4th grade had not advanced one iota. Not much to show for 30 hours of instruction per week for three months.
College was a bit different. They blew through 2 years of high school physics in a couple of lectures. This was a tremendous shock to me, and frankly terrifying. I learned I could not afford to miss one lecture, or even be late, let alone 3 months of them.
Three things:
* The normal pace anywhere -- even most colleges that are not CalTech or MIT -- is for chumps. It's slow so that everyone can keep up.
* On the other hand, I don't think your experience is representative of current middle class (and above) schools. Students complete a whole lot of what was previously considered college curriculum before graduating. Many of the students at my school graduate with >1 year of college credit, and this is despite the non-remedial curriculum floor in colleges moving up from decades ago.
* I don't think you can generalize your experience. You are very intelligent. Your experience (and mine) are not representative of overall student performance or problems.
That depends on what you mean by teaching. Explicit formal instruction with at least some attention to abstract principles is basically unknown in non-literate societies. People are generally terrible at it without experience. Observational learning is something people are amazingly good at, and language helps a lot but teaching isn’t even a universal in human societies. Watching and learning with occasional, minimal correction is.
Anyone who wants to learn more should read The Anthropology of Childhood by David F. Lance.
Many parents teach their preschoolers the basics of reading before they enter school. Those parents have no special skills. My parents taught me arithmetic as a preschooler. My 8th grade teachers were still trying to teach the kids the multiplication tables.
(Personally, I suspected those kids knew the tables, they had just figured out that they could keep the teachers stuck in a loop by pretending to fail all the tests. This way they would not have to learn any more advanced material like fractions AAAAAIIIIIEEEEEEEE!!!!! This looping business was made abundantly clear to me later, when other students bragged to me how they snookered the teacher into failing to advance.)