[1] https://www.bart.gov/news/articles/2018/news20180606
Edit: Clarified what the issue was.
?? This is a 2018 piece describing how they moved from cylindrical wheels to an advanced wheel profile. I don't think they're claiming the new, non-cylindrical profile is particularly advanced, either, but just carefully optimized to maintain a single point of contact even as the wheel wears.
I write this not as an apologist for commuter rail, which I find excessively expensive and inflexible outside of very circumstances, but as an excuse to link to the lovely Feynman description of why train wheels are tapered:
Turns out, it was.
... uhh, your own link says otherwise, emphasis mine...
>To answer the question, the original BART wheel profile, you can consider it like a cylindrical section of pipe. While the new profile is tapered, like a curved barrel, if you could imagine that the cylinder shape pipe rolling down a slight incline it really just wants to go straight. It doesn’t want to turn to the left, it doesn’t want to turn to the right, it just wants to go straight. That’s what our original BART wheel is like. Whenever it would come to a turn the wheel flange is what makes that wheel turn and go around the curve and that results in a lot of extra wear. The new wheel shape that we call the BT-3 Wheel Profile tends to want to self-center between the rails and it even steers in the turns so the result is much less wear and noticeably less noise.
The old wheels were cylindrical but the rails were tapered to provide self-centering. This works well for straight track and large radius-curves. The trouble with conical wheels is that too much self-centering can induce sideways oscillation at high speeds. BART was designed for 80MPH, a high speed for the time and still fast for a transit system. BART was also the first rail system to have active suspension. Rail geometry, wheel geometry, and suspension all interact.
High speed rail wheel and track profiles are a complicated problem. The Shinkansen system in Japan did a lot of work on this, as did the TGV developers in France. It took a while to get wheels, rails, and suspension to all work together well enough for high speeds. Now this is reasonably well understood, but it wasn't when BART was designed.
[1] https://www.wheel-rail-seminars.com/archives/2016/rt-papers/...
Now this is reasonably well understood, but it wasn't when BART was designed
Claiming that BART was ground breaking and could've never predicted the consequences of their design choices is quite revisionist. They got called out for their dangerous train control almost immediately. 80 MPH is not and was not high speed. Amtrak trainsets were cable of over 100 MPH back in the mid-70s. BART just reinvented everything poorly (that's their MO).Anyways here's a technical piece about BART wheels:
https://www.bart.gov/sites/default/files/docs/noisereport.pd...
With trued wheels and smooth ground rail on ballast and ties, BART is one of
the quietest vehicles. in operation at U.S. transit systems.
Problem is BART is exceptionally hard on their track. Even with conical wheels you can feel the new trains bounce up and down on wildly out of round wheels. You can feel the rumbling on the decrepit track between Lake Merritt and 19th St. Normal railways often lubricate their tracks, but BART can't. Normal railways increase the track gauge slightly in curves (because most train cars don't use differentials), BART pretty much doesn't.This was my favorite bit:
Of these two types of curving noise, wheel squeal is the more prevalent,
while wheel howl may be limited to lightly damped aluminum centered wheels
such as used at BART. In fact, wheel howl may be unique to BART, because
BART is the only transit system employing rigid aluminum centered wheels.
Whoops.Actually gauge widening in curves is to some extent probably more a remnant of steam locomotives with their comparatively ginormous wheelbases.
Based on current knowledge, a slight gauge widening on straight track and a slight gauge tightening on tight curves might actually be more beneficial – while trains don't have differentials, they normally (BART and some streetcar systems excepted) use conical wheels, which can self-steer themselves around curves down to a certain radius. That radius is somewhere in the range of a few hundred metres, but its exact value depends on the equivalent conicity of the combination of wheel and rail profiles.
A higher equivalent conicity reduces the minimum radius down to which self-steering remains effective, while a lower conicity reduces hunting and increases stability at high speeds on straight track. Simultaneously, given a nominal track gauge, a slight increase in the track gauge reduces the equivalent conicity, while a decrease of the track gauge noticeably increases equivalent conicity.
Based on current knowledge, a slight gauge widening on straight track and
a slight gauge tightening on tight curves might actually be more beneficial –
while trains don't have differentials, they normally (BART and some streetcar
systems excepted) use conical wheels
Right, BART got the track gauge wrong when they were using flat wheels. Instead of self-centering the wheels got dragged down the track. This went on for forty-odd years which is how BART earned its reputation for being so damn noisy.absolute nonsense.
nevermind that the shinkansen opened a decade before BART, the pioneer zephyr hit 112 mph in _1934_. while the dynamics of the wheel-rail system are complex and still the subject of active research, the need for conical wheel profiles was well-known when BART was designed. the choice of cylindrical wheel profiles was purely a symptom of not-invented-here syndrome, and BART being designed by aerospace engineers. the best excuse they could come up with for that decision is, uh, muni did it first.