The companies are the ones pushing this "security" stuff, because they want to stop us from doing things like jailbreaking --- and eventually running any software they don't approve of. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32905587
He used to write very useful utilities which did things that Microsoft didn't officially support or otherwise approve of. That's what made him famous and respected. Now he's using his position to amplify what is effectively a completely opposite viewpoint and betrayed what gave him that respect.
I'm no fan of MS now, and I guess neither Russinovich anymore, but they both used to be far less user-hostile.
I can tell you the way I felt about security and open architectures at 25 is very different from the way I feel about them now.
I also feel very different now than I did 2-3 decades ago, because I realised the importance of freedom and how we are slowly losing it.
(Jailbreaking has always been an arms race, and memory corruption exploits may eventually reach their natural end. But that'll probably be because of things like PAC, not Rust. When that happens, I expect jailbreakers to move onto the next low hanging fruit.)
This is just another one of a series of small steps.
No. Rust saves countless hours of frustration by eliminating frustratingly-hard-to-debug mistakes that humans commonly make when writing programs. Rust is pedantic, so you don't have to be. Rust saves companies money because Rust software requires noticeably less maintenance. Try it sometime.
Don't worry, I guarantee that man will always be able to break what man can make. You don't need to demonize better software hygiene out of fear that companies will perfectly lock down their devices.
"We are not truly free if we do not have the freedom to make mistakes."
I guarantee that man will always be able to break what man can make
Not with the rise of strong crypto.
Java isn't used for OS-level stuff (and I'm glad that it isn't.)
Regardless, you certainly have a warped perception of security. My OS not behaving as it should because someone forgot to remove a pointer from a ring buffer after its data was freed thus allowing malware to compromise my hardware and my personal information--possibly my livelihood--just so you can jailbreak your phone easier is so insanely idiotic it's beyond me. The right solution, if you care about owning your hardware, is to buy a device where you're allowed to replace the secure-boot keys with your own so that you can participate in the advances in security that we've made over time. Or pass a law that requires companies that sell hardware to provide boot loader unlock keys similar to what we did with SIM cards.
Also, java has been used for embedded, real-time, and system level stuff. The Android system notably, ran Java when it was born. And likely so does your bank card.
There are ways to have secure programming languages and secure boot and also own your hardware without yelling at the clouds and wishing them rain 2008 back down on you...
We don't build bridges that fall down and declare that we've done it out of the need to preserve freedom to experience gravity.
Software engineering is an engineering profession and building reliable software that works as intended is the goal. It's never been the goal to build breakable software... It's been a side effect of decades of engineering compromises to make a product buildable with the tools and resources available at the time. Tools and resources are better now, and it's high time we stopped building things that make it easy for an attacker to steal from your grandmother by compromising her bank's website.
I can assure you that systems will still be hackable and I can assure you that if they aren't, it will be of value to somebody to build a flexible at-your-own-risk system from first principles. The vast, vast majority of humanity is best served by having tools that do what they are designed to do.
I would think that someday I would stop getting shocked by things I see on Hacker News, but the "We need to keep using c++ because buffer overrun attacks are good actually" mentality is a new one on me.
There needs to be a balance. Any extreme is dystopia. I'm just pushing back because I want to restore that balance.
Hackers are a non-protected minority. And they're generally smart enough to think their way out of the world being made harder to hack. For the rest of us, most changes making the world harder to hack are improvements. That's one of the reasons the marketplace keeps rewarding such changes.