As a casual rider you'll be the bottleneck for years before your gear matters even the slightest
As a casual rider you'll be the bottleneck for years before your gear matters even the slightest
For absolute performance, maybe, but for enjoyment of riding the gear definitely matters. For a beginner it's important that the ride is enjoyable so they don't get discouraged and call it quits.
For relative performance against yourself, and in all honesty that's most of us really get out of it in the end, it's good to see times drop and speed increase just because you bought a better bike.
For me it was the other way around, I moved from a very aero cheap fixed gear to a boxy (but with a plentiful cassette) midlevel gravel bike. I was expecting that the gears I had extra would make me have faster times, however the fat tires and less aero profile makes me about half a minute slower for a 6km round. The power I'm pushing however, has increased, maybe because I can keep it more uniform by shifting to lower gears when I get into windier sections. Shrug.
All I want to say is that good gear is beneficial, maybe not for performance, but definitely for enjoyment of a ride. And at the beginning that's pretty important for someone to build a habit out of riding.
IMO there is not actually a ton of what you talk about. If anything, it's the opposite, a ton of really inexperienced folks posting about their first 20 mile ride. Note that this isn't a bad thing, just that serious cyclists aren't really hanging out there.
Calling a kit cosplay attire is silly though. There are huge benefits to a bib and a jersey.
I'm not wearing spandex because I need to be the fastest guy. I'm wearing it because it has a chamois, convenient pockets, and is a bit more aero (which means that days with a killer headwind are slightly less bad)
It is however really important to get the posture and pedaling technique right. Way too many people in expensive gear do push-only instead of a push-pull. That’s like biking 101. It’s much better to get that smooth pedaling and core support. It’ll prevent injuries and fatigue.
My body never got this until using fixed gear. The whole circle is important.