1. I download legal podcasts / radio shows and listen for stuff I like.
2.Then I'll maybe go an MP3 site and check I have the right stuff / listen a few times to make sure I'm happy.
3. Once I know I want the music I order the CD or sometimes if I feel like splashing out, and its available, I'll order the vinyl.
The joy I get from music and the importance it has to my happiness and productivity means I'm getting a good deal.
I have no idea if the artist gets a better deal because of it, but I hope so. The real reason I do this. MP3 sound quality is not the same and Spotify just sounds flat to me. (excluding your compressed to all fuck pop songs)
edit: Also I can honestly say, I do not have one pirated piece of music on my machine. That makes me feel good :)