Jeff Bezos is buying up single-family homes to rent-trap humanity forever
survivingtomorrow.org
survivingtomorrow.org
Define “stopped” in this context.
Never mind that the author incessantly links to himself.. What suggestions does he offer?
We’re on the road to serfdom. Great. Cool. What do?
However, I don't understand why the author needs to have a solution to present? You wouldn't ask the person running into your burning home to tell you and your sleeping family that the house is on fire for a solution, would you?
People need to sound the bell.
> That investors are extractive parasites who weaponize capital to passively extract wealth from the contributor class.
I’m reminded of David Friedman’s explanation as to why this isn’t the case:
> Marx argued as follows: Goods are produced by workers using tools (machines, factories, and so forth). The tools were themselves made by earlier workers. All production is done by workers, either current workers or past workers. But the capitalist claims some of the return from the production. His justification is that he has provided the tools; this is invalid since the tools were actually produced by previous workers. The capitalist who, having contributed nothing to production, takes part of the product is obviously stealing from—exploiting—the real producers, the workers. The trouble with this argument is that it does not recognize that paying for tools today and waiting for years to get the money back is itself a productive activity and that the interest earned by capital is the corresponding payment.
It’s the same for mortgages and renting. If we banned renting and required people to purchase their shelter with 100% cash (no loans), people would live in much worse homes (or be homeless). The investors provide the capital to build the homes much sooner than they otherwise would be, then wait decades before recouping their costs. They also assume quite a bit of risk. A lot can go wrong before they make their money back.
But let's look at an empirical fact: We've seen how easy access to capital(some to investors, some to buyers) has created a global real-estate bubble.
Creating easy access to capital for real-estate investments is excatly what this startup does, so the results should be the same if this becomes common.
The hypothetical not only bans renting but also mortgages, which is an artificial constraint introduced to make the case stronger. One could, of course, ban renting without also banning mortgages.
But even then the argument is insufficient to answer the original claims. Even if we grant that there is a non-zero value in the timing flexibility provided by use of capital, how does this argument answer the claim that the profits flowing to investors are outsized, distorting the housing market?
In other words, short of banning renting entirely, one might propose a tight cap on renting profits, putting returns more in line with other investment opportunities. This argument doesn't address that possibility.
(And yes, I know some landlords struggle to make any profits at all. This is not the win people who bring it up seem to think it is, because it suggests that some people are distorting real estate markets for no gain at all!)
Does it have to? Couldn't we find another answer? (Like maybe: we humans are driven by our desires and its society's obligation to prevent/reduce/limit the damage we do to others as a result)
That said, Jeff Bezos is a ghoul.
You can't win a game of Monopoly if you enter the game a few rounds after it started.
And you don't think that these points have anything to do with eachother?
> How is that true for a person who is born today?
A person born today doesn't need to buy anything from Amazon. They just don't. They may want to but it's not necessary. A person born 50 years ago doesn't either. Makes no difference when they're born.
There's also the laws which allow (or don't prevent) this concentration to occur. The usual litany includes:
- the tax bracket for the wealthiest should be 90% or higher, like it used to be.
- have a global wealth tax
- remove Taft-Hartley limitations on union power and prohibit so-called "right-to-work" laws.
- have strong protections for renters
"Amazon has secured $670 million in tax breaks this year" - https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-tax-breaks-670-million-g...
"Inside Amazon's massive subsidy in Niagara" - https://www.investigativepost.org/2022/09/02/inside-amazons-...
"Amazon Is Thriving Thanks to Taxpayer Dollars" - https://newrepublic.com/article/146540/amazon-thriving-thank...
If all my business had for the year was tax breaks, I have no revenue.
I showed you quite a few sources totally into the billions of dollars.
Now you've moved the goalposts - and that's on only one point of the several I mentioned, which themselves are only a subset of "the usual litany."
I no longer find this exchange interesting.
Consumers don’t feel any ownership of the bigger picture. Most people refuse to make ethical purchasing decisions and happily give their money to people they know are doing terrible things.
How can that be changed?