It has turned into a walled garden where the people who got in early have the credentials to participate and get help while also risking losing the clout that got them there and everyone else has little opportunity to get help overcoming their personal hurdles in becoming competent programmers.
Volunteer based answering will always lead to some kind of reputation economy, and those seem to attract assholes.
Say it costs $0.75 USD to ask a noob question. The answerer receives $0.50 USD of that. The asker gets to pick the person who answered them best, and failing that, upvotes would decide whom the spoils go to.
It would be easy to game such a system. Ask your question, get the answer, have a sock puppet account also post that answer, pick your sock puppet as the winner, only pay $0.25 for your question to be answered and stiff the person who actually put the work in to solve your problem.
If it were upvote based, people would have multiple sock puppet accounts to upvote their sock puppet answer.
Adding money into the mix makes it more difficult by a massive order of magnitude. Stack Overflow could open a paid noob question area and profit immensely from it, but a newcomer would first have to build the audience, get participation, and then introduce the payment system while working constantly to guard against sock puppets ruining the system.
Anyway, if you are going with this, billing by the question and gathering your answering team by random are sure ways to break it. You have to somehow limit the amount of questions people can ask, have long term relationships with both sides, and make sure the asking ones won't expect that every single question can be answered.
Personally, I would bet on Stack Overflow being positioned in a way where trying this would certainly fail. It looks way more likely that something like a "Red Hat School" could do it.
(But when one can make a comment saying "I know who can enter this market! It's IBM!" that's clearly a problem.)
A member of the group (it was a Swift Language group) asked a fairly reasonable developer question. It was sort of a "I have this technical problem, how do I solve it?"
This was something that I had actually solved, many times over, quite easily, so I answered it.
Surprisingly, my answer was ignored, even though it was the first one, and nailed the problem on the head.
Instead, a flood of "answers," came in, all recommending some developer tool/site.
They all got acknowledged. Some resulted in a bit of back-and-forth, between the asker and the answerer.
I noticed that all of the answerers were of the same nationality as the asker, and realized they were shills.
It was "guerrilla marketing."
I use SO all the time but just search for other people's answers and apply them to my existing problem. To some extent this is simply more convenient for me (I don't have to wait and translating a solution to my context builds my skills anyway), but the institutionalized antipathy to general/conceptual questions make it feel like an unfriendly environment.
What benefit is it to learners if search results are full of SO threads going back and forth on the exact same topics across multiple threads?
Sure, it's better for a new programmer to learn how to adapt solutions to fit their use case, and sometimes you will stumble across gold, but there's still a walled garden that decreases the likelihood that a new user will stay around long enough to be able to utilize the resources.
Not to mention the rampant elitism and dismissiveness of the current user base where new users are frequently spoken to rudely and condescendingly, in my experience. There is psychological punishment around every corner for incompetence even though many people try coming there in order to eliminate their incompetence.
The Arduino official forums, for example, are filled with toxic people who are often fairly skilled but whose replies nearly always drip with condescension. It's to the point that when I'm searching for a problem and find a discussion on their forum, I already expect to see it, and I'm nearly always right.
I'm sure there are other similar forums.