This guy gets it. I have been passed over and screwed over for years. I worked above my level for 2 years without a promotion and a meager bonus. When they finally started talking about a "promotion" it would be a 13% increase in hours for a 7% raise, and higher expectations. They also wouldn't follow their own policies, to my detriment.
Basic psychology says I was conditioned to do the minimum because I get treated and paid basically the same whether I work hard in do the minimum. You reap what you sow, Mr CEO...
Last year I got a bad rating because there was extreme context switching and I was "slow" (management was terrible and said they expected to burn people in a year or two). So I got almost nothing at the end of the year - effectively a 4.5% pay cut.
If you're doing the job, take the bump in title/pay.
I can't help but feel this is rather naive advice, not because of what it is but because:
> my manager left 9 months ago
If you're going to ask for back pay, ask for nine months and cite this as why. It would also look bad if you accept the back pay and just quit immediately, regardless of how you feel about treating your employer that way (personally, I wouldn't care about doing this if I feel like a cog). That might come back to bite you depending on future employment prospects.