Why SpaceX Is at Risk of Bankruptcy Part 1
medium.com
medium.com
NASA and the US government will be foolish to let it disappear via bankruptcy. If the company gets in real trouble, we will suddenly see that NASA will award it a long-term contract for its services that will get it out of trouble. Right now Space X is the best space option that the government has available. As long as it can deliver, Space X will continue to exist.
There's no way Space X will disappear due to bankruptcy any time soon.
No thanks.
And if you bail them out, what motivation do they have to behave like an entrepreneurial company?
Space exploration is one of those problems that are inherently difficult enough that you can do everything right, and still go bankrupt.
Musk has the wherewithal to manufacture the Falcon 9 without government funds. With them his victory is guaranted.
To the extent that the SpaceX business model is about selling rockets and not about selling other products, the government is an excellent customer. SpaceX can also offer the service of getting payloads to orbit.
Now it's possible, it has to be done.
> To the extent that the SpaceX business model is about selling rockets and not about selling other products
SpaceX's business is selling launches to orbit. Its great achievement to date is changing the expensive first stage from being a consumable (used up at the time) to being a fixed asset (a machine) used for launches.
I'm a pretty big SpaceX fan, but what exactly are these applications? Point to point? Ability to launch bigger payloads for the NRO?
The only issue is that already, launch is not the largest cost component of space assets, it’s the assets themselves.
Say Starship could launch 5 NRO assets at once, could we afford to build them?
This is only because they are essentially one-off projects.
Plan to launch 100,000 of something: launch costs start to become important.
This could somewhat understandably result in a nuclear exchange.
Those just off the top of my head. I'm sure military analyst types could come up with more.
The devil is in the details. The Starship stack requires major ground infrastructure on both ends unless it’s one-time use. See: mechazilla.
So it’s anywhere on earth where you’ve had a couple years to build the “stage zero” infrastructure which includes a giant propellant tank farm, and the logistics to fill said tanks.
Regarding other theoretical applications, the only one that is not truly sci-fi is the ability to launch Starlink size swarms. But use of kinetic anti-space asset weapons are also likely the end of space access. It’s a very fragile theater up there.
Yes, it needs an (automated) aircraft carrier fleet equivalent, or bases strategically place around the world. Not really a problem.
The kinetic weapons, I was assuming, would be aimed at ground targets. Directed energy weapons for space targets (and very unlikely for ground. The atmosphere is thick.)
I would imagine it would be better to pre-deploy SF teams close to potential theaters of operation. Then get them closer by normal means.
I think I just described what JSOC currently does btw.
So I still don’t know what this magical 45 minute cargo would be.
Disclaimer: I don't think anyone has seriously proposed using Starship like this, have they?
The “killer feature” is kick starting an aerospace revolution, no matter if that’s civilian or not.
If you’re in an aerospace career, you know that the commercial aviation industry has been in a steep decline.
The “air” part is struggling, but imagine the applications coming from the “space” part. Just manufacturing in space is a massive opportunity.
Edit: I am no fan of military stuff. It'd be much better if all that went away: it's a drain on our ability to make life better for everybody in the world.
But we live in the world in which we live, not some utopia.
The conclusion seems to be that after raising $10B, SpaceX can't justify it's $127B Private Market Valuation.
The chart shows Starlink projected revenue to be $15B in '22 and over $20B in '23 and operating income of over $5B in '22 and $10B in '23.
If these numbers are anywhere close to correct, is bankruptcy really a possibility?
Even if they were 2 years behind schedule and only had operating income of $4B and growing at 80%+ per year, couldn't they raise another $5B if they needed?
I’m sure folks with hunting cabins in the Maine wilderness are thrilled that Elon is burning investor dollars to bring them broadband Internet at $100/month, but doesn’t that market tap out pretty quickly?