https://www.militaryaerospace.com/commercial-aerospace/artic...
https://www.militaryaerospace.com/commercial-aerospace/artic...
If you want to use hydrogen for aviation, LH2 is really the best answer, since the percentage hydrogen by weight is much higher. The next best thing would probably be an sofc using hydrocarbon fuel, if you really wanted to go electric, but still needed endurance.
Hydrogen must be stored as a compressed gas or as a deep cryogenic liquid. Either way such tanks are expensive, heavy, and create safety concerns. Hydrogen is a very pernicious molecule, and leaks cannot be detected by human senses. All hydrogen vehicles and fueling stations need special sensors to detect leaks. Hydrogen is much easier to ignite than gasoline. Any concentration from 4-74% will explode in air, and the flame is nearly invisible.
Refueling a hydrogen tank involves going from high pressure to low pressure, which causes the fuel line and nozzle to get extremely cold. Even in southern California, refueling a few Toyota Mirais causes the nozzle to freeze to the valve. This limits refueling speeds and duty cycles.
Lastly, hydrogen is far less efficient as an energy storage medium. With a battery, you put electricity in and get electricity out. It's 80-90% efficient. With hydrogen, you use electricity to split water, then compress and liquefy the hydrogen, then run it through a fuel cell. The fuel cell itself is 40-60% efficient. At the end of the whole process, around 30% of your initial electricity comes out of the fuel cell.
Off the top of my head I can think of biofuels plus carbon neutral recaptured co2 from excess renewable energy.
Diesel electric motors for example with the ‘diesel’ being carbon neutral biofuel. This is actually being tested on large airbus jets currently.
Hydrogen is one of the worst possible options for aircraft. Energy density is crap, tankage is heavy, failure modes catastrophic.
Having said that, with future automatiion, I do feel there's room for aircraft that combine and re-assemble themselves in mid air. For example, a VTOL tug that lifts off and starts a craft flying, but then detaches and returns to base.
This can potentially be repeated on the landing side, and even mid-air "re-fueling" via battery drones.
Possibly I just watched too many kids shows where vehicles did this and it's now my equivalent of the Jetson's flying cars.
Feels like the next crazy project for Silicon Valley Billionaires to look into now that electric flight, jetpacks, rockets that land vertically etc. are all solved problems.
Trains are a solved problem, Japan, China and France show how it's done. No need to wait for miracles or SV billionaires - ffs, Hyperloop was (likely) only created to disturb the planning of California's HSR [1]!
[1] https://jalopnik.com/did-musk-propose-hyperloop-to-stop-cali...
Trains are cool though. One big EU project currently is to connect up the train lines better across borders which are often still country centric in their network layout, which defaulted the medium distance capital to capital journeys to air transport.
The CA HSR project was started in 2008, when voters passed Proposition 1A to provide $10 billion to fund high speed rail between SF and LA with a maximum travel time of 2 hours and 40 minutes. Initial estimates were that trains would be running by 2022 with the project completed by 2029 at a cost of $33 billion.[1] Construction started in 2015. Now the official projection is to have trains running between SF & LA in 2033 at a cost around $100 billion, though in reality the two cities will likely never be connected.[2]
High speed rail doesn't make much sense in most of the US. The country is so big that most routes would take significantly longer than aircraft, even counting the extra time spent in security and traveling to/from the airport.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_California_High-Spe...
2. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/may/29/california-h...
It seems like an obvious choice to me.
Perhaps if you store it in a balloon? But then volume would bed a problem for an aeroplane.
[0] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/347258594_Operation...
Battery swapping has repeatedly faceplanted when it comes to cars, but it's a pretty different scope of challenge, and it seems like every major issue is more favourable to aircraft.
On the other hand, planes are often on the ground for 2+ hrs between flights anyway, so maybe it could be realistic with enough power delivery capability to just charge a big pack in situ. Certainly simpler to plug in a big umbilical at the gate than having to have another ground vehicle reaching into the belly of the thing.