Letting people out of prison is not a simple undo function there are dangerous side effects as experienced in California
Letting people out of prison is not a simple undo function there are dangerous side effects as experienced in California
something like 80-90% of ALL cases at the federal level end in plea bargains, mostly for practical reasons because the legal system literally doesn't have the capacity to handle all the charges that would be brought forward. pretending it's unique to simple marijuana procession is fearmongering
>Letting people out of prison is not a simple undo function there are dangerous side effects as experienced in California
the US has 25% of the world's prison population and 5% of the world's population, the ONLY worthwhile moral consideration is the mass release of US prisoners. stuff like "think of the side effects" just perpetuates the stays quo via perpetual "considerations"
I love this reasoning. If there are no non-violent offenders, then every crime is violence. Considering people break laws on accident all the time, it is probably safest to simply imprison the entire population of California by default and have a tribunal of police that decide parole on a case-by-case basis.
If non-violent crime is indeed rare, would you be eligible for parole in my thought experiment where everybody starts off incarcerated? How could I trust that you wouldn’t violently jaywalk or violently forget the contents of your trunk and bring an apple across state lines?
Serious question: Do you work in or for law enforcement? The only people I’ve ever spoken to that maintain “people that smoke weed are indistinguishable from rapists and murderers” are people whose income in some way relies on holding that opinion.
I’m just a civilian victim of crimes who knows that releasing criminals causes crime.
If you want to see proof, look at crime rates in CA cities, Chicago, Baltimore, New Orleans . Those cities have been letting prisoners out letting suspects out with no bail.
Almost all crime is committed by a small percentage of people. You don’t have to let many criminals out for big increases in crime.
You’re concerned about the criminals and I’m concerned about the victims.
Your point is that people in jail for weed are probably violent? Based on what?
I’ll repeat my earlier question:
> Serious question: Do you work in or for law enforcement? The only people I’ve ever spoken to that maintain “people that smoke weed are indistinguishable from rapists and murderers” are people whose income in some way relies on holding that opinion.
Also I’ll add my second question: Since there are only two groups of people, “violent criminals” (since all criminals must be assumed to be violent) and “victims”, what group does someone that’s wrongfully imprisoned fall into? Who exactly do I care about then? Criminal or victim of a shitty criminal system?
Also, would you get parole in the world of “guilty of violent crime until proven innocent” world? I’m fascinated about your willingness to make theoretical statements paired with your allergy to answering theoretical (and while we’re at it, basic factual) questions.